LogFAQs > #977074891

uhhh i'm running out of time here to make a case so let's try and make this quick

Corrik7 posted...

I been trying to bury Ashe all game, but I think we might have to lynch JC here right now. I am not entirely sure we should allow him another even phase.

I am pretty sure he did not have to reveal himself as the Box owner. Which does in a way express a dilemma. Why would he have revealed himself if he didn't have to and is an even day serial killer. But, on the other hand, it made someone more likelier to take it if he tried to sweeten the pot and possibly had a choice to spare them and so on.

JCs role is clearly nefarious. The right play here might be to eliminate that.

The problem ofc is... timing. 4-8-1.

We take him out. We are 4-7 tomorrow. We aren't mylo but we are darn close to it.

Let's say we lynch right today. JC again let's assume offs a town. And scum shoots a town.

3-6-1. We could never kill JC going forward without being at actual mylo. So, we kinda have to kill him today if we don't wanna be a mylo after.

And that's assuming this is also a correct lynch. Let's say this lynch is a curveball wrong.

4-5-1. We pretty much have lost at that point.

UltimateBrohan posted...

Makes a lot of sense. i dont think Ashe lynch is wrong but i hadnt considered the JC indy angle. i also like EDumeys post #201 im on my phone i cant quote it properly or just dont want to. Dangling carrot etc. Also hate the defense of why would i do this scummy thing as scum maybe youre just bad. Would like JC to clarify what else his role can do and when he does it in extreme detail but A) you mightve done that already and B) you dont exactly give trustworthy. May switch my vote later if i read this shit and form actual thoughts and opinions who knows.
Zoom interview today Say good luck Brohan 3 times in a row to bless me and my descendants with cash money

(the corrik post is what brohan quoted, for context.)
this post felt really scummy for me. it's very strange to me that of all the posts he could have commented on, he picked corrik going off the deep end suggesting JC has multiple additional kills that he can somehow do without using the box / getting lynched and said "yeah this sounds reasonable". and basically doesn't say much of substance, much like he's done all game.

it kinda feels like he just pops in every once in a while, picks one or two choice posts to be like "yeah that sounds good to me" and just plops his vote down on somebody. maybe he's overwhelmed or whatever but to me it just looks scummy to just be a bystander agreeing with some truly inane shit. it feels like designed to make corrik think he's onto something and keep going off the deep end on some of these theories.

and on day 1 which i no longer have time to go back and pull he's like randomly vote swapping a bunch without saying much of anything which i don't particularly care for either.