LogFAQs > #892691944

K181 posted...

Two things:

1) Actors don't control the characters. He may not like the direction they went, but just because he played the role decades ago doesn't mean his opinion trumps all others.

2) I'm not sure what Luke means by "Jedi don't give up" when he then went on to say that maybe he'd take a year or two to regroup, as that's essentially exactly what Luke did.

2 I agree with but 1 is way more grey than you made it out to be. Completely depends on the creative control that actors given IMO. If you have creative control through a trilogy and then don't decades later you certainly have a right to state "that's not the same character" because you were contracted to play someone else's interpretation of said character.

Unless the majority of his lines and actions were scripted he certainly has a voice in the matter even if it doesn't amount to more than just being his opinion.
---

Typical gameFAQers are "Complainers that always complain about those who complain about real legitimate complaints."-Joker_X