LogFAQs > #892952978

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, Database 2 ( 09.16.2017-02.21.2018 ), DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	My only gripe with The Last Jedi is Finn's entire story / plot SPOILERS
Giant_Aspirin 12/27/17 1:56:10 PM #14:	destrian522 posted... A group of young heroes come up with a low probability chance of success plan to save they day, except its poorly thought out and they fuck it up. People die. did anyone die as a direct result of their actions, though? people died because the Resistance was cornered, which would have happened regardless of Finn and Rose doing their thing, right? the orders were to just chill and wait, which the Rebellion did without even knowing Finn and Rose were doing their thing the entire plot ended up in the exact same place it would have without them doing that. the only thing it contributed to the story was developing Finn's character as a hero, instead of a passive observer. Vol2tex posted... Giant_Aspirin posted... Vol2tex posted... The subplot directly leads to their evading transports being fired at and the battle at Crait. wouldn't that have happened anyway, though? like, if Finn didn't exist at all and that didn't happen, wouldn't the end result be the same? the rebels would have had to fall back to Crait either way, it was the only place to go. The First Order was focusing on their big ship and didn't know about the evading transports until the codebreaker informed them. shrug. i guess. but that's an awful lot of screen time to dedicate to having the FO figure out that the Resistance fled to the closest planet <_< --- Playing: Hyper Light Drifter (PC), Cuphead (PC) *(~);} - Get out the pans, don't just stand there dreamin' - {;(~)* <cite>Giant_Aspirin posted [p:892952978] in My only gr... [t:76141424]...</cite> <quote><cite>destrian522 posted...</cite> <quote>A group of young heroes come up with a low probability chance of success plan to save they day, except its poorly thought out and they fuck it up. People die.</quote> did anyone die as a direct result of their actions, though? people died because the Resistance was cornered, which would have happened regardless of Finn and Rose doing their thing, right? the orders were to just chill and wait, which the Rebellion did without even knowing Finn and Rose were doing their thing the entire plot ended up in the exact same place it would have without them doing that. the only thing it contributed to the story was developing Finn's character as a hero, instead of a passive observer. <cite>Vol2tex posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Giant_Aspirin posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Vol2tex posted...</cite> <quote>The subplot directly leads to their evading transports being fired at and the battle at Crait.</quote> wouldn't that have happened anyway, though? like, if Finn didn't exist at all and that didn't happen, wouldn't the end result be the same? the rebels would have had to fall back to Crait either way, it was the only place to go.</quote> The First Order was focusing on their big ship and didn't know about the evading transports until the codebreaker informed them.</quote> shrug. i guess. but that's an awful lot of screen time to dedicate to having the FO figure out that the Resistance fled to the closest planet <_< --- Playing: Hyper Light Drifter (PC), Cuphead (PC) (~);} - Get out the pans, don't just stand there dreamin' - {;(~)</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1