I enjoyed the movie. But Holdo refusing to tell anyone about her plan was completely stupid.
Yeah see this I actually get. It's a genuine problem and a clear contrivance from the writers
LapisLazuli posted...
XIII_rocks posted...
Nobody actually hates it because of that,
You would be surprised by how nuts some people can be.
But that's what I'm saying - people don't think the movie sucks because of that, they came out not liking it for other reasons (character stuff like how they handled Luke, not liking Holdo, etc) and then used it later to bolster their argument against the movie.
Similar: friend of mine arguing that because of the directors changing, they might make Rey's parentage different to what it was revealed as in TLJ and therefore the reveal is stupid, irrelevant garbage. My counter: it makes sense that Kylo would lie and trick her in that situation, so you're basically looking for a meta-criticism rather than treating the movies on their own terms.
So wait. You are arguing no one can dislike the movie for reasons other than you agree with or they are making them up to bolster their argument?
What world do you live in??? That is an insane way of thinking. ---