scarletspeed7 posted...Corrik posted...
scarletspeed7 posted...
Corrik posted...
Literally Endor. Yavin 4.
Know the movies before you make posts that do not make sense. Jesus.
I disagree that they were in "as dire straits" in either of those films as they were here. At least they had a working plan for Yavin 4. At least on Endor they had a working plan and an armada that could take something down by sheer attrition. What I saw in Episode 8 were 5 ships falling prey to a lack of leadership and planning. What the Rebels had in 4 and 6 did not exist here.
4 that is valid. 6 not valid. They thought they were literally fucked when that shield was up and the imperial fleet was there. To tell me a single commander wouldn't have emptied via transports to other shops and suicided his ship to save the entire rebellion fleet is silly. And to say the imperial or rebellion fleet would mass up in formations like those if that was a possible tactic is silly also.
They had A) people on the ground and B) a much more competent and larger fleet that they could angle against the Star Destroyers. The fleet's issue was the destroyers and not the Death Star. And the fleet's largest capital ship, once it was destroyed, was all that really needed to be handled.
Whoa disagree totally.
What exactly are you saying here?.
The odds were impossible against the rebellion. The imperial fleet was not supposed to be there at all. Let alone a SSD and a bunch of SDs... And a shielded DS2 with a FULLY OPERATIONAL battlestation.
---
LoL ID = imajericho
XBL GT = Corrik
... Copied to Clipboard!