if standard horror movie rules apply green auto loses. Just saying.
im not black though, im not green dragon however i think i may actually be getting votes because people think i am so you know what, sure i'm green dragon
getting to the original post, I would win and here's why. Jack is too worried about his own image. doubting his own attractiveness, he would never be able to focus on the trials at hand, and would instead look in the nearest mirror, internally freak out about his looks, and post a picture on potd so that everyone would tell him how attractive he actually is. that is, of course, if he could even make it that far before being killed. I, on the other hand, have no such issues, and would have the ability to concentrate fully on escaping.
Oh, well shit. Also, I'm a former marine, a trained fighter and a Deputy Sheriff. I'm 6'8" and 230 pounds. Those guys ALWAYS get killed in horror scenarios. The stoner guy wins in the end. I probably get killed by a small demon child with a rubber band gun or soemthing.