LogFAQs > #900490275

_MorningStar posted...

Which is what he did. And your argument was that because he listened to Gamora and tried to kill her, that somehow makes what he did to Thanos out of character.

Not out of character, I am saying he is capable of acting both emotionally and logically. And in the Thanos scene, he acted emotionally and is responsible for what happened to half the universe.

But the person you love most in the world asks you to do something, you are at least willing to listen. He doesn't know any of the ones on Titan trying to stop him. And he never tried to kill Gamora for the greater good, he did it to ease her suffering. Because she begged him to. T hats emotion, not logic.

That's logical right there, if he was acting emotionally during the Gemora scene, he wouldn't have shot her. If he truly loved her and acted emotionally, he wouldn't have listened to her logical decision. And instead opted for "I'll just save her later and apologize, she will forgive me and we will treat it like another one of my lovable goofy moments". Instead, he made a logical decision to denounce his emotions and kill her. Which again, makes the decision to overreact emotionally to her death, even though he was trying to kill her prior to that scene, even more, proof of how much he fucked up.