LogFAQs > #906319132

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, Database 4 ( 07.23.2018-12.31.2018 ), DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear
Topic List
Page List: 1
TopicChris Music Mafia 2: Consequences
benjamin3740
08/05/18 4:43:15 PM
#418:


ScareChan posted...
benjamin3740 posted...
Hey Scare, I have a weird question for you. Be honest - how much do you desire ranking in Chris' patented top 3 players?


None at all.

It's these posts that led me to ask you this question.

ScareChan posted...
I would be shocked if zam is not just scum watcher

And none of the people I listed were people I said were busting him.

Han, zach, plum are the ones that were involved where he messed up saying it was auto correct and similarly last game he messed up players that were posted here in topic tjay were all town. So that's town points to all I feel

Dumey is the only guy zam voted today so also town points

In fact the only person I said is sketchy is sultan because that is a possible Bus. Especially if you go out and see how the vote went down


ScareChan posted...
So assuming zam is scum

Tony lock town

Han, zach, plum, dumey all very likely town


For reference, these were made by you after Tony counter claimed watcher, but before he admitted to being scum. At this point, Alakazam was not at all confirmed to be scum, and you seemed to have already decided that he was. Enough to take the next step and start saying players who interacted with him in certain ways were town. This came off to me as either a town who was being "extra" to a fault (perhaps trying to be MVP), or a scum who is bussing Zam and already knew he was scum with nothing to stand on. Someone who knew how the day was going to end. I will explain why I felt that now.

I've hardly ever seen someone set up so many reads on players in advance before the player who's interactions you are judging even flips. I dont think you could have been so confident in Alakazam's scumminess to truthfully have all of those reads with so much confidence. Especially since you are well aware of Zam's "sketchy plays" as both alignments.

But even with you being confident Zam is scum this game, you listed 4 people after Tony - basically anyone who interacted with Zam at all during the period where you saw him break, and called them all "very likely town". I think there is a huge gap in potential towniness from those interactions between Zach and say...Dumey. I think calling them all equally "very likely town" wraps it up in a bow too nicely and you could easily fit a scum mate or two into that list who look good coming out of the Zam interactions.

I have one more thing to say, let me go quote it
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1