LogFAQs > #906450897

Corrik posted...

Have you said who the 5 scum are yet Panthera?

Leo is obvious, I definitely still lean scum on FD.

So off the top of my head, town reads are Zach, Puns, Tony, Eaed, Han, Scare.

Leaves

Sultan, IGCD, MZero, PJ, Red, Tange, Crescent, Dumey, Ben, Death, Corrik.

I kind of feel Tange is town despite his limited contributions, doen't feel all that different from the last time I played with him where he was town (he's a bit more focused on irrelevant stuff here, but I don't know how much it really means). Corrik Claims are always a risky thing to believe but I can tentatively buy him here. Crescent seems like she's probably town, little leery because I think her writing style and fondness for harping on the same point until something comes of it comes across as very pro-town when it's more a personality thing, but I'd put her more towards the town side of the pile regardless.

Sultan, IGCD, MZero, PJ, Red, Dumey, Ben, Death. 8 players left.

Of the bunch, Sultan feels likelier to be newbie town. MZero hasn't made me think he's scum yet so that's a good thing, plus he had an interaction with Han day 1 that I kind of liked. Basically he asked Han for an opinion on FD immediately after Han gave an opinion on FD, then said after he was wanting to know why. Little hard to put into words but it kind of felt genuine to me, it's not a hard read but it makes him a bit lower priority than some others in this group. Red feels the scummiest here, I'm a bit hesitant because I feel like his lack of strong opinions so far must be at least partially due to a lack of time to play or something because there's no way his scum game is as simple as "barely post, ask pointless questions once in a blue moon" but there's a definite lack of real reads from him and that's not what I'd expect. Feels like he's trying to emulate aspects of his posting style but without the usual substance.

So Leo/FD/Red scum, in descending order of confidence.

IGCD, PJ, Dumey, Ben, Death.

Assuming at least one scum in there, maybe both if I'm actually being good at this for a change lol

PJ has given nothing to really work with besides some claim stuff that may or may not be serious (not just the miller claim, but joking about picking good night actions when Ben made his "clutch save" post, for example, obviously not claiming protection but it's hard to tell if he's trying to bait a shot as town, faking it as scum, or just having fun as either). IGCD has some really weird posts like when he briefly though Tony was scum who fake countered Zam on the assumption town had no Watcher, and generally was posting without seeming to be really thinking it through on day 1 (he justified it as having not caught up, since he did just replace in). Stressing that weird doesn't necessarily mean scum, he was fairly neutral in my eyes until just now when he decided to act like there isn't anything to say. That's blatantly not a pro-town mindset. It's not guaranteed scum since town does/says dumb things sometimes (hi guys it's me) but pushes him closer to the scummy side in my eyes. Death I haven't gotten a handle on yet but he hasn't done anything that makes me sure he's scum like in Blade mafia so that's nice.

Dumey and Ben have both given me cause for concern, although Ben has also had some moments that feel like they probably came from town (his attack on Scare during day 1 twilight, why he didn't like me believing Puns immediately). Dumey I don't really like how he followed me/Sultan onto Leo, with Leo being scum that looked like trying to look like he was making a train on scum happen but knowing it was a train that was unlikely to go anywhere.

So after Leo/FD/Red, probably Dumey. I can't really narrow down who exactly I think the last one is right now.
---

Meow!