LogFAQs > #923099353

red13n posted...

This is part of where my faith in both you and mzero was lost btw. Because you both bought into the dumb "ulti did this last game"(He didnt) and didn't have much(any) of a reaction when I flat out told you that it wasn't the case.

I bought into initially because there was nothing to contradict it. After you said otherwise, I thought about it but with you and Corrik saying different things, I had to go with Corrik being the guy I trusted more to be town and my own knowledge that Ulti is a bit more fond than most scum players of killing players over killing roles. The exact specifics of the last game were less important than thinking about what might be going on in this one, and Corrik's point about Ulti has some merit to it even if the example he gave might not have been a perfect comparison (which again, I don't know with certainty because I didn't play in that game).

5tarscream posted...

I didnt dismiss the flavour angle at all in any way. I was asking what people thought about it and Corrie dismisses it then said oh actually my flavour does have something to do with me. Im not saying the characters are matched to people Im saying the flavour attached at least seems to have some sort of tenuous link to the player.

What flavour was I "supposed" to have? And what makes No Way Jose the perfect only possible flavour you could have ever been assigned?

Your argument is literally that Sultan rigged the game in town's favour by giving people flavours that match them to ensure that scum is auto-fucked the moment they claim because the safelist won't be catered to them in particular. It's dumb.

Corrik7 posted...

Panth, why 5tar and not red or puns?

I think he's the most likely. His thought process has just never added up as town, whether it was his twisted logic on suspecting Scare even though he was saying he'd changed his mind on the reason why (thinking Death was scum) or his selectively trying to paint himself as looking better by discussing his day 1 play while leaving out that he suspected Death and Scare and saying that the main people to attack him all game have been scum as a point against me while neglecting to mention that the person who first attacked him and did so the most on day 1 was Scare, to this garbage flavour crap that just doesn't work as a way of trying to figure out who is scum and who isn't.

Red I can at least see the argument that he left his vote on Tom day 1 and his day 3 play could have come from a town perspective even if I suspect it didn't. Puns is more on my radar from PoE than anything else, I can't feel confident in him being town but he's the least likely of these three.. The odds of them being town are higher than 5tar. I just struggle to see the case for him being town here.
---

Meow!