Okay Puns is town, reread the beginning of this topic if you doubt it. He's genuinely annoyed at how Ulti is attacking his activity. Like, look at that and tell me the mindset is anything but "what the fuck is this guy for real attacking me for this stupid shit". It does not read like fake, forced anger at all. That said I don't get the case on Ulti, how is that mixing up his suspicion between games (is this even a thing that happens?) when he's using the fact that you went to sleep to explain why you didn't post for a while to try to show you were only lower on activity last game when you were busy, unlike this game in his mind? That doesn't really add up to me.
SBell has been super defensive and kind of defeatist this game, like the majority of his posts are getting frustrated at suspicion of him and lamenting it (what was with that post about not being vengeful enough to be okay with being mislynched?). That said it's starting to feel more like an attitude thing than an alignment thing. I don't want to lynch him today as it stands, but I do like several of the people on him, so could Han, Ulti or Puns (I know you just unvoted but you're there in spirit) reiterate the case on him beyond just him being kind of frustrated/mopey?
Not liking IGCD pretty much saying he doesn't feel the need to provide any thoughts, I know people are saying that he's like this in general but that's kind of an easy excuse to hide behind. IGCD, you said at one point that you felt like people were just posting a whole bunch of nothing. What about the discussions that had been going on made you think they weren't particularly relevant? Right now that's feeling like just a way to give yourself an excuse for not posting much by acting like it's not worth your attention anyway.
Still pretty sold on Death being scum. I want to draw attention to this post to add to what's been said before.
htaeD posted...
actually Eaed could replace Puns on that list If only for this confusing waffle of a sentence I just came across.
-Corrik feels like scum, at the time it seemed like he had a true contraction on Death. It makes me like Corrik but I like Corrik early last game too.
He later backed off on it when Eaed said he'd mistyped and meant to say "feels like he's hunting scum" (lot of words to forgot, but okay). When I saw this post, I got confused for a moment and then realized Eaed just typed the wrong thing. I do not trust putting Eaed on the Gladiator target list over this when it's so easy to realize what was meant. If he said he disliked the post for the hedge on Corrik, sure, but he only went to that after Eaed clarified what he meant to say. This feels like someone just going for an easy/obvious contradiction to push instead of really thinking things through to figure them out.
Ulti, you said you think Death *is* trying to figure the game out and that as scum, he fakes activity. I don't see him trying to figure things out, and he's posted a lot while being pretty non-committal and got caught up in the Corrik argument for ages (in fairness, Corrik is good at distracting people). What are you seeing here differently than I am?
Pez, how recent is your experience playing mafia with Tom? You seem very sure he hasn't changed his play. In particular, why was his little flavour trap thing against Corrik a play you can't see him making as scum?
Death is scum. Don't like IGCD much. I'm seeing a lot of talk about Red being a scummy lurker but no one seems to want to do anything about it, which is fine by me because I don't really see it (Red is often lurky as town and he has reason to be busy here). Tom has been very fluffy. Actually Tom why were you treating Han/SBell as if it had to be scum/town and not town/town, but thinking that either could be the scum (though you lean more to SBell obviously)?
---
Xbox Live User Name - Corrik Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3