LogFAQs > #937345797

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, Database 6 ( 01.01.2020-07.18.2020 ), DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear
Topic List
Page List: 1
TopicPercussion Mafia Topic 8 - Day 4 starts here
Crescent-Moon
04/13/20 9:06:58 PM
#6:


Now then, I want to reanalyze their actions day 1 because I see some juicy things looking back...

DamionDL posted...

##Vote: Lea

My gut is saying this nightmare of Lea posting is Scum trying to make sure Puns is lynched. I don't like it.

Damion's last post of day 1 was a splinter onto Lea. He says it's because Lea's trying to get Puns lynched, while Lea is on Panthera. The vote looks bad in a vacuum. The reasoning is awkward and isn't explained well. You know what though? This post is on the right track. Scum wanted Puns lynched over Panthera. This post feels like it's too on the money about scum's gameplan to have come from scum. This post singlehandedly greatly improved my stance on Damion.

Lea splinters off of Panthera almost as soon as the tiebreaker starts. Asks why Chris is town.

Leanansidhe posted...

Oh Puns, they're gonna murder the hell out of you for that

This is Lea's reaction to Puns' claim. It's... Why?

Chris actively defends Panthera's tiebreaker inactivity, and Lea posts this:
Leanansidhe posted...

He probably just didn't see that there was an actual literal tie in this hell year 2020 but he'll die for the sin of not claiming oh well, maybe he's scum
This post is a disaster. It both defends Panthera and says Panthera might be scum. There doesn't seem to be anything that justifies any of Lea's actions in the tiebreaker. Lea is flat out not trying this game. I'm actually going to be mad if Lea is town and is playing in an intentionally anti-town manner just so she can get herself killed and BS post as a ghost. I honestly would want to put her on ignore for the rest of the game if she flips the role she's claiming.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

##unvote

###vote:Chris

Yolo!

This is one of only two posts Sultan has in the tiebreaker. He has absolutely no given reason for getting off of Panthera or going onto Chris.

DYL has no posts for the last 23 hours or so of day 1, but like both other days, was there shortly after the day ended to post his nonsense after not being present anywhere near EoD.

People I don't want to lynch today:
Tange, Scare, MZero, Death, Uwnim, Damion, Corrik (Corrik I'm adding reluctantly, but I feel the game doesn't add up if Corrik is scum.)

People we need to kill ASAP:
Panthera, Masterplum

The last scum: Lea, Sultan, DYL

This is my current game theory. The modkill cost us a mislynch (The game would practically be over already if it didn't happen), but it means we can test MZero at some point. Given Corrik's claim that MZero has a bomb on him, this seems prudent. I don't think scum MZero fakes this and scum should never have a role that's unlynchable. Scum had a hyper bomb and town has no direct killing power. "Deathproof" doesn't make any sense to be scum. Two bombs on the scumteam doesn't sound right either. Even if he doesn't explode, I'm comfortable calling him solidly town if the lynch doesn't kill him and leaving him at that.

I really hope we get out of tonight with some sort of scan on Corrik. He's the one X factor that worries me the most. I'm worried a lot of our actions are going to get burned on the two already obvious scum.

After we lynch Panthera and Plum, we make someone in that third pool hammer MZero and see what happens. That's probably our best bet. Any power claims we still have left (And with Uwnim, Sultan, Scare, and Tange are all claimed scanners, at least one will still be alive... Well, and I guess Corrik is also a claimed scanner) will get their results before we move into lynching into that pile and give us the most possible information. That's of course assuming scanners don't catch the last scum before then, and that MZero doesn't just explode and take out the last scum anyway.

[4] Hb - (Corrik), (MZero), (Sultan), Balla, Lea, Sultan, (Corrik), Death
[3] Balla - (Lea), (DYL), (Scare), Hb, (Sultan), Plum, Panth
I just looked at this again and this is interesting. There's 3 scum on Balla, but both Lea and Sultan are not, even though they were on Balla at some point. Sultan switched from Balla to Hb after the claim.

Wait a minute, these votes are wrong... Corrik never unvoted Hb before voting for Panthera. I'm not sure how this was entirely missed by everyone, which includes me at the time. Hb ended the day at 5 votes.

So some more tidbits I just noticed while looking at that:

masterplum posted...

I hate these reaction HB votes

Balla, explain your thought process picking chris night 1

The two reaction Hb votes were Sultan and Lea, two people he's tried to make out to be potential scum no matter what happens. Why is he not attacking either of them for this? It was a comment Plum made for the sake of a comment. Sultan AND Lea (who came out of nowhere) have their Hb votes be their last post of the day, each. Hb's vote actually looked rather awful at 3.

It's kind of absurd just how similar the vote patterns of Sultan and Lea have been this game.

masterplum posted...

You guys are acting like scum always acts perfectly. I'm super confidant balls is scum thinking hb is lying

Crescent-Moon posted...

Why would scum think Hb is lying? Why would Hb lie to begin with?

uwnim posted...

Actually full doc trying to act like something less than he really is so he comes across as harmless.

masterplum posted...

Ask corrik why he claimed cop as vanilla or whatever. Sometimes people do things.

Or maybe some power affected something. Idk.

Uwnim is the sensible town reaction. Plum is the scum reaction that reaches for justifications.

---
I'm a kitty cat and I'm ok. I prowl all night and I sleep all day
She's a kitty cat and she's ok. She prowls all night and she sleeps all day
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1