LogFAQs > #962632114

Teddie > Koromaru > Kitty

I don't see why there's any debate. Teddie is the best-developed of the three and his puns are critical to the party's chemistry developing - he really adds a lot to the dynamics (and he acts like a teenage male, so IDK why people have a problem with that, especially considering Yukiko flirted with him too). His identity crisis and trying to find out what he even is gets him a lot of points since that's so easy to relate to. Teddie's also the best in battle of the three.

Koromaru has a good design and a versatile moveset, though his damage output is pretty bad. His backstory is pretty simple and we don't get anything interesting with that... I haven't played P3P though. Purely talking the original here. P3P may help me have a reason to actually remember him.

Kitty is the worst character in battle in P5 because his defenses are so paper-thin that he dies before he can perform the healing he needs to. He's also the most obnoxious of these three, and it's not just due to him being what the game uses to tell you to go to bed because you have something the following afternoon. It's also how his Ann fetish is creepy due to his insistence that he's human... when he's not.