considering she was voted out in probably the most exciting and unpredictable tribal councils of the entire season, you'd think she would have gotten more screen time than she ultimately did. That being said, I thought her hair was pretty cool.
That moment when all the Galu's are bracing for impact at the reveal of who is going home was pretty intense. That was the only moment of the entire season where I felt anything for Kelly. I mean, I didn't like her, and I was glad she got voted out. But the way they portrayed that scene made me feel a little bad for her. But she certainly does deserve a low ranking, for the reasons you state. And yeah, her hair was a better character than she was.
Oh, and this insignificant first boot was brought up four seasons later at the reunion when David Murphy proposed to her live on national television, and you know she wanted to say no.
And this was so much better than anything she did in Tocantins. Has there ever been a more awkward Survivor moment than that? It hurt just to watch.
All-Stars is, without a doubt, entertainment-wise Rupert's weakest performance
I was never able to even look at Rupert objectively that season, just because of how much I liked him in Pearl Islands. But he definitely wasn't very good, although I could still never justify ranking him this low. I definitely believe all the Survivors who played with Rupert who say he wasn't really that entertaining or enjoyable as America thinks, because if what they showed of him in All-Stars is all they had to work with for the most well-liked Survivor of all time, prior to All-Stars, then....well...I guess he doesn't really do much! Rupert really got lucky that Pearl Islands was a pirate theme, because he just ran with that all season, and he played it amazingly. The show Pirate Master even tried to emulate a contestant that was like Rupert, but he didn't even compare.
GUESSES:
325. Mary?
324. Nick Brown
323. Matt
322. Julie. Maybe Jim?
321. Natalie T.
--
http://kotti.wippiespace.com/survivor/datass2.gif
http://tinyurl.com/82d9keg