The topic is about fucking them, not talking to them.
Yeah, but I've considered personality to be a significant factor in sex appeal for decades now. My usual hat trick is Face + Body + Personality. If someone's smoking hot but a complete bitch, I'm less interested.
And if you reduce it purely to the level of physicality, I don't find either of them all that exceptionally cute, nor do either of them have a body type I'm all that interested in. They both need to eat at least a few sandwiches.
Not saying I'd kick either of them out of bed or going the stereotypical Internet nerd route of saying 2/10 would not fuck, but still, I'm not really salivating over either of them.