LogFAQs > #908315445

24 Nominations:
2B - NieR: Automata

22 Nominations:
Aqua - Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep

21 Nominations:
Victor Sullivan - Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

15 Nominations:
Guile - Street Fighter II

14 Nominations:
Estelle Bright - The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky

13 Nominations:
Chloe Price - Life is Strange
Kazuma Kiryu - Yakuza
Max Caulfield - Life is Strange

12 Nominations:
Godot - Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney: Trials & Tribulations
Joker / Ren Amamiya - Persona 5
Monika - Doki Doki Literature Club

11 Nominations:
Metal Sonic - Sonic CD

10 Nominations:
Waluigi - Mario Tennis

9 Nominations:
Kate Marsh - Life Is Strange
Velvet Crowe - Tales of Berseria

8 Nominations:
Ellie - The Last of Us
Geralt - The Witcher
Hat Kid - A Hat in Time
Michel Bollinger - The House in Fata Morgana

7 Nominations:
Aloy - Horizon Zero Dawn
Cuphead - Cuphead
Green Biker Dude - Mega Man X2
James Sunderland - Silent Hill 2
Metal Man - Mega Man 2
Monokuma - Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc
Nightmare - Soulcalibur
Rathalos - Monster Hunter
Red - Transistor
Sans - Undertale
Tear Grants - Tales of the Abyss
Vivi - Final Fantasy IX

6 Nominations:
Makoto Niijima - Persona 5
Master Hand - Super Smash Bros.
Noctis Lucis Caelum - Final Fantasy XV
Pichu - Pokemon Gold/Silver
Richter Belmont - Castlevania: Rondo of Blood
Shovel Knight - Shovel Knight

5 Nominations:
Android 21 - Dragon Ball FighterZ
B.J. Blazkowicz - Wolfenstein 3D
Bulbasaur - Pokemon Red/Blue
Ditto - Pokemon Red/Blue
Goro Majima - Yakuza
Phoenix Wright - Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
Rabbid Peach - Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle
Shulk - Xenoblade Chronicles
Tetra - The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
Vincent Valentine - Final Fantasy VII

4 Nominations:
9S - NieR: Automata
GlaDOS - Portal
Mog - Final Fantasy VI
Mr. King Dice - Cuphead
Neptune - Hyperdimension Neptunia
Urdnot Wrex - Mass Effect
Yuna - Final Fantasy X

3 Nominations:
Big Boss - Metal Gear
Bowser - Super Mario Bros.
Cao Cao - Dynasty Warriors
Captain Falcon - F-Zero
Jigglypuff - Pokemon Red/Blue
King K. Rool - Donkey Kong Country
Liquid Snake - Metal Gear Solid
Lu Bu - Dynasty Warriors
Magus - Chrono Trigger
Maya Fey - Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
Mewtwo - Pokemon Red/Blue
Octodad - Octodad
Rikku - Final Fantasy X
Rydia - Final Fantasy IV
Simon Belmont - Castlevania
Skate - Streets of Rage 2
Snorlax - Pokemon Red/Blue
Sora - Kingdom Hearts
Tidus - Final Fantasy X
---

Black Turtle did a pretty good job.