| Topic List | Page List: 1 |
|---|---|
| Topic | Let me talk about Umineko 2!!! *still continue to not spoil me!!* |
| GANON1025 10/07/18 9:05:16 PM #82: | If we go that route, why not cast doubt on the calls themselves? In reality, Natsuhi is the culprit and we are being shown these calls between her and a mysterious man in order to obfuscate her movements. Like, the fact she has no alibi the night of the first twilight is explained because "she was forced into it by a mysterious man", but could just as easily be "she performed the killings, perhaps with Krauss, and will claim to have been alone in her room all night later." This line of reasoning has two holes I think. One, Genji took the calls from the man. Genji didn't recognize the caller, and he has no reason to lie about a call coming in to Natushi alone. By that I mean, if Natsuhi was with people maybe she and Genji could have colluded in secret to plan a fake call. But by themselves there's no reason to lie about what is happening. Second is that I see no reason why Natsuhi or Krauss would kill Jessica. So right now I find it hard to believe either of them are the killer right now. --- ... Copied to Clipboard! |
| Topic List | Page List: 1 |