LogFAQs > #910559776

rexcrk posted...

I guess its cool if your favorite aspect of Star Wars is the battles? Im trying to think why people hold it in such high regard, and that is definitely where it excels.

Pretty much. The characters were indeed pretty one-dimensional and forgettable, but for a one-shot spinoff story about people who never get mentioned again in the series, I feel that's fine. Realistically, no other single Star Wars movie does all that much to flesh out its characters anyway, with most of the development happening on a series scale. As a movie about wacky space adventures and laser battles? It's excellent, and easily some of the best the series has to offer, and I loved that about it.

darkknight109 posted...

I also appreciated Rogue One because it took some elements from the Original Trilogy and made them more intimidating by giving them a modern look.

I especially liked Vader's appearance on the ship at the end. That's possibly the most intimidating he's ever looked, and the scene beautifully conveyed the fact that everyone on board was ****ed without being flashy or overdramatic (see: most of the PT) about it.
---

This is my signature. It exists to keep people from skipping the last line of my posts.