LogFAQs > #925011015

I'll add my voice to the chorus that Lopen was no where near town MVP.

Lopen it might be right that if town had followed you, town would've won. But town didn't follow you because you're starting points continued to be way off. You couldn't lead town. Ben had a similar problem. He couldn't get me lynched without a scan. He did try on D3 at least twice by the way. I think you guys figure out he scanned me scum and lynch me D4 if we kill him N3. You would've lost the Death scan though probably. Ultimately Ben was sussed out as cop for any number of different reasons. He could've played better, but his screw up didn't cost town that much.

You repeatedly cost town. Chris was exactly right it was the bandwidth thing. You soaked up all the attention town had. Cam did this a little bit, but people mostly grew to ignore him. I'm not sure he gets lynched this game if he wasn't a flavor miller that town felt like they had to lynch.

Lea - HB/Sheep - Cam mostly fell in the neutral category. They didn't really hurt town or help town.

Tom was actually a plus to town. He made a couple of nice thumbs. In particular thumbing SBell wound up being really useful. But he thumbed me and I think had it setup that if he died that night so did I. So, if I had been the one to send the kill I think Tom dies and then you guys lynch me. But I'm not sure you guys actually would've read Tom the right way. I really don't know why people thought he was scum, he was pretty obviously town.

Lolo claiming BG was fine. Could've used the power on Chris D2. But instead used it on the claimed scanner. I don't blame him on that choice. Every night after that I believe he protected a scanner. Lolo claimed at the time he did because of the HP flavors floating around. The only reason Lolo came close to getting lynched was because Tom just happened to be a third form of weak protection and I timed a B8 special that had a low chance of working, but I thought it was worth the effort because if it worked we saved ourselves a NK and if it didn't I had my "reads" on Tom that I breadcrumbed to show why I voted.

Corrik didn't need to claim. But this is a simple mistake and one made in a single moment when he thought he had something damning. He made up for it with a nice save on Lolo. It was the clear choice and we really should've killed him. But we were afraid of EBG and decided we could risk the delayed death but we couldn't risk Death dying at night. We needed him to soak the lynch. Corrik saving Lolo made it possible for Lolo to actually prevent a kill by soaking a second bullet. This didn't turn into anything but could've and was on balance better than anything you provided.

TLDR You may have had better reads than most of town, but the way you played it had the most negative impact of any player in the game. Everyone else was at least a net neutral if not a net positive. To be fair to you some of that was because they had power roles and therefore had more margin of error. But the fact remains, you cost the town more than any other single player this game.