That's not the one I take the most offense with. That would be Scot Pollard, but I hate Roberta-Christine and Jim Rice too. Holly would be fascinating to see play again.
I'm rewatching Redemption Island at present and it's not as insufferable as one might think pre-merge - it's actually quite good, but I know it's all downhill after the second Wyatt Nash blindside - so I feel it would be so interesting to see a more mature Stephanie Valencia play again. Her biggest problem was naivet, but there was also that Zapatera is by far my least favorite tribe in Survivor history too. The only person I like is Sarita because she's the only one to show emotion and be authentic and relatable. Everyone else is either a pompous jerk, a clueless twit, or some combination thereof. David reminded my dad of Big Wendy from EOE, which is spot on. The only difference is the fact that David had solid logic in regards to why he disagreed with his tribe; everything thereafter was virtually identical. I could go on and on as to why I don't like that tribe, but I'll just end with saying I'd much rather be on Ometepe, if only to be able to cuddle with Nat Ten >_>
Of Russell's list, I'd like to see Holly, Rodney, Billy, and Stephanie, but would REALLY REALLY like to see both Nat Bolt and Boo. Russell hasn't been that insufferable lately - his "Top 10 (actually 11) Survivors that will never play again" video was great because for once he wasn't talking about how great he is. The list was mostly on point, but the two-for-one made zero sense lol ---