LogFAQs > #931057175

Pitch Voting:

MLA vs X-Treme

All of MLAs problems remain as he hasnt even tweaked his stuff. His stars are relegated to minor roles, the overall gist of the book is strong and has a definite direction....which is more than can be said for X Treme
Johnbobb

Brotherhood vs Mutant Intent
Brotherhood.....this is an improvement but it's still SUCH a mess. Ultimately a choice needs to be made I feel between Vulcan and X Man as there is just so little common ground here.

Also your book is now intensely focused on mystery solving which is not a role Cyclops fits well. This is a team that need either like Beast or some X Force Investigations peeps to bring it home.

Mutant Intent meanwhile is so threadbare but simple.

Ultimately....Bananors book is still the one Id rather read but this was a poor matchup

Wickle

Red has chosen not to address his books problems while Wickles is still amazing.

X-Kin vs Mutant Underground

First of all these are both much more compelling than last week.

X-Kin sounds AMAZING. I know you won't ever get her from Rocket but X-23 would turn this book into a long term fan favorite. As is still a really excellent pitch.

Mutant Underground is really starting to come together with just an excellent roster but much like johnbobb you are just burying your only actual drawing card. Still super intrigued about where your book would go.

I give CPU the edge albeit barely.

Fight:
Chichiri
redrocket
Martin
DC

---

Board 8's Voice of Reason
https://imgur.com/AWY4xHy