LogFAQs > #933866286

Oh hey, my votes were identical except for Foxworth I think. I struggled with Foxworth because CBs are so unproductive stat wise and all my own team comparisons were nowhere close even without the return TDs. So that kinda tipped it over for me.

Weddle was another I struggled on. I actually wrote No then Yes and then back to No. Again I compared him to my own dude and figured his stats were good but not great. It was just the length of time he did it for that was impressive. My SS outperforms him on a season by season basis but won't come close to his career stats because he just won't play anywhere near as many games. I wasn't sure how much to value the consistency across a career though

Edit: And yeah with Chukky I went yes even though the rankings for him suggest no. That career sack/block ratio is that insane for a C even for a few seasons, nevermind an entire career. I did remember you highlighting how crazy his stat line was a few seasons back when we asked what was a good ratio for an interior O-line player