LogFAQs > #936748924

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, Database 6 ( 01.01.2020-07.18.2020 ), DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Game of the Decade: 2010-2019 Contest Analysis Crew - Part 2
Master Moltar 04/04/20 1:47:24 AM #128:	Round 1 Fallout: New Vegas vs. The Stanley Parable Moltars Analysis So Fallout beat Bioshock Infinite in 2015, right? Well, in the only previous poll for The Stanley Parable, it lost handily to Bioshock Infinite in it! I think that means New Vegas wins this due to the maths! Plus New Vegas >= Fallout 4 and VVVVVV > Stanley Parable Moltars Bracket: Fallout: New Vegas Moltars Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas 80% ____________________________________________________________________________ transiences Analysis New Vegas should be pretty strong. Stanley Parable.. not so much. It's a quirky little narrative thing that people certainly like, but it didn't spread super widely and I think it was more of a game that came and went about 5 years ago. I'm not sure if New Vegas has a wide enough playbase to go super high here, but it should be able to get around the 80% that every other game has put on bottom-tier fodder. Stanley Parable isn't on the level of an Obra Dinn, but it's a far cry from the ones who have looked decent. transience's prediction: Fallout: New Vegas with 82.44% ____________________________________________________________________________ Leonharts Analysis I feel like we already kinda saw this match! Its a well-liked Fallout game against an obscure indie game. Im not sure what new insight I can provide other than that! Is New Vegas more popular than Fallout 4? Is The Stanley Parable more popular than VVVVVV? Who knows! We saw New Vegas do pretty well in 2015, and weve already seen that Fallout 76 backlash isnt hurting the other games in the series that much, at least not in a situation like this. I imagine the final result wont be too different from what we saw before. Leonharts Vote: Fallout: New Vegas Leonharts Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas with 71.72% ____________________________________________________________________________ Kleenexs Analysis Fallout 4 looked preeeeeetty good against VVVVVV. Given we have a game arguably more popular in New Vegas, against a game arguably less popular than V in The Stanley Parable, I think we see a similar result today. Im not actually completely convinced that New Vegas is stronger than 4, but they should be relatively close indirectly. Stanley is almost assuredly weaker than V (based on zero factual evidence), so its possible we might even see New Vegas put up a bigger result than 4 did. Kleenexs Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas with 73% ____________________________________________________________________________ Guests Analysis MetalmindStats BlowoutFAQs would already be enough to ensure a convincing win for New Vegas here, but on top of that, I think this is a nightmare match for The Stanley Parable. Both games are praised most of all for their writing, both are heavy on player choice within their narratives, and both are PC-centric, with New Vegas fans considering it the true successor to the early PC-exclusive Fallouts. However, between possible antivotes and The Stanley Parable likely having more strength than the Obra Dinns of this field, I dont expect New Vegas to quite contend for the biggest blowout of the contest. Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas wins with 80.35% ____________________________________________________________________________ Crew Consensus: Man theres so much fodder here... --- Moltar Status: hype Contest Analysis Crew Archives: http://thecrew.speedrunwiki.com/ <cite>Master Moltar posted [p:936748924] in Game of th... [t:78534198]...</cite> <quote>Round 1 Fallout: New Vegas vs. The Stanley Parable Moltars Analysis So Fallout beat Bioshock Infinite in 2015, right? Well, in the only previous poll for The Stanley Parable, it lost handily to Bioshock Infinite in it! I think that means New Vegas wins this due to the maths! Plus New Vegas >= Fallout 4 and VVVVVV > Stanley Parable Moltars Bracket: Fallout: New Vegas Moltars Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas 80% ____________________________________________________________________________ transiences Analysis New Vegas should be pretty strong. Stanley Parable.. not so much. It's a quirky little narrative thing that people certainly like, but it didn't spread super widely and I think it was more of a game that came and went about 5 years ago. I'm not sure if New Vegas has a wide enough playbase to go super high here, but it should be able to get around the 80% that every other game has put on bottom-tier fodder. Stanley Parable isn't on the level of an Obra Dinn, but it's a far cry from the ones who have looked decent. transience's prediction: Fallout: New Vegas with 82.44% ____________________________________________________________________________ Leonharts Analysis I feel like we already kinda saw this match! Its a well-liked Fallout game against an obscure indie game. Im not sure what new insight I can provide other than that! Is New Vegas more popular than Fallout 4? Is The Stanley Parable more popular than VVVVVV? Who knows! We saw New Vegas do pretty well in 2015, and weve already seen that Fallout 76 backlash isnt hurting the other games in the series that much, at least not in a situation like this. I imagine the final result wont be too different from what we saw before. Leonharts Vote: Fallout: New Vegas Leonharts Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas with 71.72% ____________________________________________________________________________ Kleenexs Analysis Fallout 4 looked preeeeeetty good against VVVVVV. Given we have a game arguably more popular in New Vegas, against a game arguably less popular than V in The Stanley Parable, I think we see a similar result today. Im not actually completely convinced that New Vegas is stronger than 4, but they should be relatively close indirectly. Stanley is almost assuredly weaker than V (based on zero factual evidence), so its possible we might even see New Vegas put up a bigger result than 4 did. Kleenexs Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas with 73% ____________________________________________________________________________ Guests Analysis MetalmindStats BlowoutFAQs would already be enough to ensure a convincing win for New Vegas here, but on top of that, I think this is a nightmare match for The Stanley Parable. Both games are praised most of all for their writing, both are heavy on player choice within their narratives, and both are PC-centric, with New Vegas fans considering it the true successor to the early PC-exclusive Fallouts. However, between possible antivotes and The Stanley Parable likely having more strength than the Obra Dinns of this field, I dont expect New Vegas to quite contend for the biggest blowout of the contest. Prediction: Fallout: New Vegas wins with 80.35% ____________________________________________________________________________ Crew Consensus: Man theres so much fodder here... --- Moltar Status: hype Contest Analysis Crew Archives: http://thecrew.speedrunwiki.com/</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1