LogFAQs > #965481745

CreekCo posted...

I explained it earlier. You cannot make an allegation in a public setting with malice that you cannot subsequently prove.

For instance, if his lawyer said it looks almost like someone went back and messed up the place then that would have been a sketch thing to say but still within speculation. He said something to the effect of accusing them of doing something and he could not prove this with either a witness testimony or video footage. So it was a baseless allegation. This does not speak to the veracity of the statement. He just couldnt prove it and as a lawyer should have known better.

Um idk if this case is just out of the ordinary or something but I'm just going to have to disagree with you here cuz they plainly said the exact opposite of what you're saying. Have you listened to the verdict? If you just listen to the actual verdict you hear them say they had to prove ALL the elements of defamation of which there are seven I believe, one of those being that the statement was untrue. They explained this during the trial. Listen to the reading of the actual verdicts and you'll hear that the jury determined she proved that statement to be false. Here, I'll get it.
https://youtu.be/8LzGWvL3ugg
Skip to 7:46, you'll hear all of the elements of defamation that one must prove, and the falsity of the statement is indeed one of them. Really it was the only one up for debate for that specific count.

And I don't get why you'd think the onus would be on Johnny to prove anything when Amber is the one filing the claim... You're innocent until proven guilty, not a liar until proven honest lol.

I really don't wanna argue with you bro, tbh idk if you know far more than I do or far less, but it just seems pretty clear what you're saying contradicts what was said in the trial and what actually ended up happening.

I have a question and it seems to me that you're giving a bad answer, like ambers testimony it just doesn't fit with the facts. And I really really want a good answer. So I have your input, and I thank you for it, and maybe it'll shake out to some how actually be true, but there's nothing to be gained by arguing so let's agree to disagree for now.