LogFAQs > #976273296

1) Lullaby - In my opinion, probably their best song. Hauntingly beautiful in both instrumentation and vocals, and one hell of an earworm. I love how vague yet hyperspecific the lyrics are - you know exactly the feeling they're trying to convey, but they can refer to almost anything the listener's imagination warps it into.
2) Lovesong
3) Prayers for Rain
4) Pictures of You
5) Plainsong
6) Closedown
7) Untitled
8) Last Dance
9) Disintegration
10) Homesick
11) The Same Deep Water as You
12) Fascination Street - You can tell this one was intended as a marketable single, but it's just not as good as the rest of the album nor another couple dozen or so singles that they put out. Not bad, but the rest of the album is better.

I actually have a more solid ranking order than I thought. Places 6 through 10 are pretty interchangeable, but everything else I'm certain of the position.