LogFAQs > #979021452

hello~

About six weeks ago I took nominations for video game songs to rank. They had to be eligible for VGMC. They had to be new to my big VGM spreadsheet. Those were basically the only requirements.

You gave me 300 songs! Jesus Christ. Yet somehow I have emerged from this auditory hallucination richer, stronger, and more vitamin D deficient. Most importantly, I have the ranking!

To say that I was very pleased with this haul would be a massive understatement. When I ran a VGM ranking five years ago, the average ranking was around 5.1/10. 5 is average to me, so collectively you did slightly above average. By contrast, the average ranking for this ranking is 6.74. And the median is 7! That is ridiculous. Maybe it helped that I gave a list of some things I liked in music. Some of you clearly tried to follow that. Some of you clearly didnt. Some of you played it safe. Some of you took risks. Some of you nominated whatever shit you felt like giving me, which is always a valid strategy.

Some trends I noticed: there was a plentiful amount of industrial noises, unique percussion, and ticking clocks. There were no child vocals instead, several songs had what Id call little girl music where a grown woman tries to sing in a high-pitched cutesy way. I guess that counts? Maybe? There were a lot of evil variants on things: evil jazz, evil ambience, evil guitars, evil sax, evil sound effects. Several songs had prominent evil laughter. There were two separate Godzilla-themed songs. What are the odds of that?

Before we start, heres an explanation of my rating system. I rate on a scale of 0 to 10 in increments of .5. 5 is average. 0 actively causes me pain. 10 isnt perfect, but is really really damn good. The lowest score any song got was a 2 (two songs). The highest score any song got was a 10 (three songs!). Anything higher than a 7 is something I consider playlist worthy. 7.5+ I would consider for use in Discord VGM guessing games. 9+ is VGMC nomination or support. You may be seeing some of these songs come VGMC season!

For the actual ranking, I have a pretty good idea of a songs rating value when I listen to it. Ive gotten to the point, 5000+ ratings later, where I can normally tell a 7 from a 7.5 from an 8. Then I look for a range: at what point do I start liking the songs, on average, more than the song Im trying to place? I get less precise the lower I get, because I dont remember lower songs on the sheet all that well. Its not an exact science. If it was, Id never do it!

Each song in the ranking will have its rank number for this ranking alongside its overall spreadsheet rank (out of 5834). I might, when we get higher, start showing other adjacent songs on the sheet (so like, the immediate songs above and below), if anyone would be interested in that. Not sure if Ill do that or not.

Heres the spreadsheet where you can view all the dropped songs, plus all the placements and ratings before theyre filled in. You can also see a list of all 300 noms, both sorted alphabetically and by nominator.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HdQJbfqMqrZnEBNZyxyZAg3ZKWJ1_rvKyoCmFJhRAaY/edit#gid=0

I think thats it. As always, Ive tried to not be too negative, even within the bottom tiers. I appreciate everyone who took the time to give me songs, even if I ranked them last place.

Hope you have a great time in the topic!