Board 8 > Rank the Telltale Games you've played

(+) Yeah! (+)

Despite really loving these games, I've only played a couple and of the ones I've played I typically beat about 2 or 3 episodes before stopping for really no reason whatsoever. It doesn't make sense.

Anyway of the ones I've played I think my favorites are

The Wolf Among Us
The Walking Dead Season 1
Tales From the Borderlands
Poker Night at the Inventory 2
Poker Night at the Inventory 1

I have pretty much all of them thanks to Humble Bundle, just need to get around to playing the others.
---

WDS1 > TftB > TWAU > GoT
---

WD1 > WD2 > PN2 > PN1
---

The Walking Dead S1
The Wolf Among Us
Jurassic Park
Tales from the Borderlands Ep. 1
The Walking Dead: 400 Days
Batman: The Telltale Series
The Walking Dead S2
The Walking Dead: Michonne
Back to the Future Ep. 1
Game of Thrones Ep. 1

Overall, the Telltale formula has really staled for me, I think they did too many series at once and the gameplay was never as good as it was in TWDS1 ever again.
---

By order-

Walking Dead Season 1
Tales from the Borderlands
Walking Dead Season 2
Walking Dead Season 3
Walking Dead Michonne
The Wolf Among Us
Game of Thrones

WDS1 is a masterpiece, it made me try to the rest of the games (no wonder as most of them are also WD lol!)
Tales From the Borderlands is also amazing
WDS2 is underrated and get a lot of hate for no reason, it isn't as good as season 1 of course but it's pretty decent
Season 3 is mostly fine but far too short and it's still not complete
Michonne was pointless I have no idea why they made that game
Couldn't like TWAU for some reason
Game of Thrones is a piece of shit and I am surprised they plan on doing a season 2 for this
---

The Walking Dead S1
The Walking Dead S2
Sam & Max Beyond Time and Space
Sam & Max Save the World
Tales From The Borderlands
Sam & Max: The Devil's Playhouse
The Wolf Among Us
Puzzle Agent 2
Puzzle Agent
The Walking Dead: Michonne
Tales of Monkey Island
Minecraft Story Mode
Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People
Poker Night at the Inventory
Poker Night 2
Batman
---

The Walkind Dead S1
The Wolf Among Us
First 3 eps of Tales From the Borderlands
The Walking Dead S2
The Walking Dead Michonne
Sam and Max Save the World
Poker Night 1
Poker Night 2

Yet to go beyond Ep 1 of Back to the Future and Game of Thrones
---

Walking Dead S1
Tales from the Borderlands
The Wolf Among Us
Walking Dead S2
Poker Night 1
Poker Night 2
---

1) SBCG4AP
2) BttF
3) Poker Night
4) Poker Night 2
5) TWD S1
---

Walking Dead S1
---

The Walking Dead Season 1
Tales of Monkey Island
The Wolf Among Us
The Walking Dead Season 2
Puzzle Agent 2
Puzzle Agent
Back to the Future
---

Tales from the Borderlands
Walking Dead S1
Wolf Among Us
Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People
Walking Dead S2
Back to the Future
Game of Thrones

I enjoyed all of them (except chunks of Game of Thrones) but it's really hard to get excited about Telltale anymore as they start to feel repetitive gameplay-wise, plus now Life is Strange did the same thing Telltale always does but managed to do it better than Telltale ever has
---

TWD S1
Tales from the Borderlands
TWD S3 (so far)
The Wolf Among Us
TWD S2

I loved all of them a lot tho
---

The wolf among us
---

Walking Dead S1
Tales from the Borderlands
Walking Dead S2
The Wolf Among Us
Back to the Future
Tales of Monkey Island
Jurassic Park
Walking Dead Michonne
.
.
.
Game of Thrones
---

Walking Dead 2 > Walking Dead 1.

IMO season 2 was way better.
---

1. Tales from the Borderlands
2. (Left blank out of respect for TftB)
3. The Walking Dead S1
4. The Wolf Among Us
5. Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People
6. The Walking Dead S2

I have GoT and been meaning to get to it sometime. Eventually I'll play Batman and TWDS3 and Michonne but I don't really care right now.

And I heard good things about Minecraft so if I ever see that on sale for a dollar I'll get it.

Oh, and I played the Poker Night games and enjoyed them both but don't really consider them the same. I guess they'd go after Strong Bad.
---

Walking Dead 1 > Strong Bad > Wolf Among Us
---

bryans7 posted...

1. Tales from the Borderlands
2. (Left blank out of respect for TftB)
3. The Walking Dead S1
4. The Wolf Among Us
5. Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People
6. The Walking Dead S2.

This is accurate, except maybe switch Walking Dead S1 and The Wolf Among Us.
---

Can we use this topic to discuss just how bad Game of Thrones is?
Not going to make the whole post in black bars so assume everything in this post is spoiler for the game -

Anyway, the game sucked. it suffers from massive problems -
1.Not the game fault, but it's set in a very tough universe..it can't do anything with the major characters. When you see Ramsey and you want to kill him, you know that you can't because the game is supposed to be "canon" and can't alter characters from the show/books
It kills so much suspense
2.This fucking scene -

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSG5ZXedQ0g
Can you really imagine something like this in the show? in the show Rodrick would have died the first time he stood up to make an example, not make the villain bitch and cry. Like, look at 6:40 when he screams "IM IN CHARGE HEEEEEEEEEERE" pathetic
This is the Game of Thrones universe, not Naruto, the villain is not supposed to be impressed you are standing up to him, he can slit your throat if he wants to
3.Suffering, suffering, suffering
Kinda feels like the first part of Season 7 of TWD. The whole game you are losing, the whole game is just despair.
Is it a bad end to always lose? no because the Starks always lost in the show..to an extent. They also won a few times but that's the thing - they won, and those victiories were sweet
Here? nothing, you never win. And when you think that you do? you get backstabbed
4.The ending. I have no idea what they plan to do with season 2 as they killed the whole house and the main character that remains is a choice character - which means this character is as good as dead (like Telltale always do with choice characters, ala TWD Kenny and Jane)

There are only two good things about it -
Asher is a great character and I enjoyed playing with him 1000 times more than any other character
And this song -

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-aETXtqOvc
Her voice is fucking beautiful
---

I think Game of Thrones (or rather, A Song of Fire and Ice) is a book series where a legitimately good author is burdening himself with an awful agenda, so I've never been interested in the game to begin with.

As for me...

Sam & Max Season 2 = Sam & Max Season 2 > Sam & Max Season 1 = The Wolf Among Us

And that's all I've cared to play :)
---

1. Tales from the Borderlands
2. Sam & Max
3. The Walking Dead S2
4. The Walking Dead S1
5. The Wolf Among Us
(didn't finish tier)
6. Back to the Future
7. Game of Thrones

I can't rank the Sam & Max seasons individually because it's been too long, but even S3 which was kind of disappointing was also amazing. I just want more.

TWD2 vs 1 I go back and forth on, but I do really appreciate the risks S2 took
---

I went into the Game of Thrones Telltale game with the highest expectations and was completely let down
---

Sam & Max S1 > Sam & Max S2 > Sam & Max S3 > Poker Night
---

Johnbobb posted...

I went into the Game of Thrones Telltale game with the highest expectations and was completely let down

On a happier note, high five to anyone having Tales From the Borderlands at the top of the list. I went into that game with low expectations (I don't even like Borderlands) and was blown away.
---

KamikazePotato posted...

Johnbobb posted...

I went into the Game of Thrones Telltale game with the highest expectations and was completely let down

On a happier note, high five to anyone having Tales From the Borderlands at the top of the list. I went into that game with low expectations (I don't even like Borderlands) and was blown away.

Same here. I like Borderlands as a game, but didn't know how it would transfer as a Telltale game. They completely nailed it.
---

The Wolf Among Us
The Walking Dead S1
Sam and Max Season 1
The Walking Dead S2
Poker Night At the Inventory 2
Back to the Future
Poker Night At the Inventory
---

Walking Dead S1 >>> Batman Telltale
---

Johnbobb posted...

Same here. I like Borderlands as a game, but didn't know how it would transfer as a Telltale game. They completely nailed it.

I had never played Borderlands prior to that and it made me want to immediately play it.

I didn't, which is probably for the best, but TftB is so fucking good.
---

walking dead s1 > s2

that's all
---

Tales from the Borderlands
The Walking Dead Season 1
Game of Thrones

You could switch Borderlands and TWD and nothing would really change. Both are leagues better than GoT though
---

WD1
Poker Night 1
Poker Night 2
Puzzle Agent 2
Puzzle Agent 1
---

1. Tales From the Borderlands

1. The Walking Dead S1

2. The Walking Dead S2
3. The Wolf Among Us
4. Tales from the Borderlands

5. Game of Thrones

i could very well have those middle three be interchangeable depending on my mood. really good stuff.

got could have been good if not for the insulting last episode that really soured me on the whole experience.
---