Board 8 > Which VGMC-retired Umineko music track is your favorite? (part 2)

(+) Yeah! (+)

Umineko no Naku Koro ni 4 - dreamenddischarger

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vYAXZs8pFU" data-time="
Umineko no Naku Koro ni 4 - Endless Nine

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYprKGl4_H0" data-time="
Umineko no Naku Koro ni Chiru 6 - Life

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GbqYuTZFDKk" data-time="
Umineko No Naku Koro Ni Chiru 7 - The Executioner

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=euezX9D3aDE" data-time="

Hopefully all the music this time is from the original game, not the anime or something!

Past results:
Umineko Part One: worldenddominator > system0 > Hope = goldenslaughterer > miragecoordinator
Xeno: Engage the Enemy (aw, yeah) > Godsibb > Unfinished Battle > Communication Breakdown > Small Two of PIeces
VVVVVV: Pushing Onwards > Potential for Anything = Piercing the Sky > Positive Force
Super Smash Bros.: Bramble Blast = King Dedede's Theme > Mother 2 > Shin Onigashima
Persona: The Battle for Everyone's Souls > Rivers in the Desert > Last Surprise > Memories of You
Bemani: Kurokami Midareshi Shura to Narite > SP DARK LEGACY Hyper = Shining Wizard > Despair of ELFERIA
NieR: Song of the Ancients ~ Fate > Shadowlord > Emil (Karma) = Automata - Amusement Park
Mega Man: Dr. Wily Stage 1 (MM2) > Title (MM3) > X vs. Zero > Spark Man Stage
Final Fantasy: The Extreme = You're Not Alone > Battle with Gilamesh > To Zanarkand = Seymour Battle > Someday the Dream Will End
Ys: Sunshine Coastline > Innocent Primeval Breaker > Desert of Despair = False God Causality
Chrono: Corridors of Time = Scars of Time > Dreams of the Shore Bordering Another World > Dreamwatch of Time
DKC: Stickerbrush Symphony> Gangplank Galleon > Fear Factory > Forest Interlude
Ar Tonelico: EXEC_SPHILIA/. > The Second Tower > Hidra Heteromycin > EXEC_REBIRTHIA=PROTOCOL/. > Moon-Dwelling Demon
Zelda: Tal Tal Heights > Dragon Roost Island > Staff Credits (WW) > Gerudo Valley
Mario: Dire Dire Docks > Beware the Forest's Mushrooms > Floater Land/Buoy Base Galaxy > Big Blue (MK8)
---

This one's much easier.
---

Life > dreamenddischarger > The Executioner > Endless Nine

Yesterday's songs were all a lot better, much easier choice

still all great though
---

The Executioner might also be a top 5 Umineko song, but:

ded > The Executioner > Life > Endless Nine.

Once again I like all of these though.

Also Hope is better than all of these still. Top 3 Umineko songs for me right now is Ricordando il Passato > Hope > dreamenddischarger
---

Life vs Executioner is tough.

ded is simultaneously massively overrated and very good.

Reg posted...

ded is simultaneously massively overrated and very good.

Agreed.

goldenslaughterer is better ;>_>
---

There's a lot of Umineko songs I've gotten tired of listening to recently

Executioner is NOT one of them and still one of my top favorites 5+ years later
---

So, uh, why'd you save six for the last topic when there's only four here?

IB4 Tomorrow and You -Destructive- aren't being counted.
---

didn't lastendconductor retire?

oh you're running 3 polls for this, nevermind. why not just 2? there's not THAT many Umineko retirees.
---

He did specify Umineko, so counting You -Destructive- wouldn't really make sense.
---

Xuxon posted...

didn't lastendconductor retire?

oh you're running 3 polls for this, nevermind. why not just 2? there's not THAT many Umineko retirees.

What I'm not clear on is how he decided the split, because it evidently isn't by episode.
---

I'm guessing he's gonna have a 3 way poll after all 3 polls are done
---

yeah i guess he split it to give wed, ded and lec each a free win before they face each other. though imo ded and lec should have been in the same match so one could go head to head against wed.
---

Errr.... none of your hypothesis are correct. I tried splitting the music up by episode, but apparently I got it all wrong. >_> I used the titles on the list-of-retirees spreadsheet as my guide. A couple of them were not clear as to what game they belonged to. Too late to fix that now, though!

I split it into three polls because I thought 6 and 7-option polls were too big, particularly for Umineko, with how long its tracks tend to be.
---

DED > Executioner >>> the other two. The former two are my favorite songs from their respective games, but the others aren't that great IMO. Probably at least 50 songs I'd rank over them.
---