Board 8 > Percussion Mafia Topic 5 - Hippopotamus Hippopotamus Hippopotamus

(+) Yeah! (+)

BallaLeonHall posted...

I thought he was town.

Why?

---

ah dammit. Who do I have ignored. Who is post 50

---

BallaLeonHall posted...

uh okay 5tar is gone also.

I thought he was town.

For what reason?

---

We should probably at least wait for claimed roles to say what went down

---

I wondered how Plum was going to replace into a game that he had a person on ignore in. Han dropped the ball on that one.

---

masterplum posted...

ah dammit. Who do I have ignored. Who is post 50

Corrik

---

masterplum posted...

ah dammit. Who do I have ignored. Who is post 50

Corrik.

---

Votals
[2] Balla - Lea, DYL
[1] Plum - Crescent

---

BallaLeonHall posted...

We should probably at least wait for claimed roles to say what went down

Have you claimed and I missed it? I have told you to claim like 8 times this game already including when you almost died day 2?

---

I unignored him

I can't even remember why I did it in the first place

---

Leanansidhe posted...

Mass claiming is the best.

I'm Neil Peart, TOWN Drum Messiah

Even if I die, I can keep on playing

You've hinted at this a couple of times now if memory serves

---

Crescent-Moon posted...

You've hinted at this a couple of times now if memory serves

Hinted? She begged to be lynched day 1.

She is still scum though.

---

Leanansidhe posted...

Mass claiming is the best.

I'm Neil Peart, TOWN Drum Messiah

Even if I die, I can keep on playing

what does that do

---

Convinces people to *not waste a lynch* on her.

---

D1 she was asking to get lynched cause she'd still be able to play even if she dies.

---

So its just a vanilla that.... keeps playing?

---

Personally I'd like to see people read 5tar's first day, and compare it to his first day in his recent games.

The only other game where 5tar was that stale and muted day 1 was Phoenix Wright. He was scum in that one.

---

Leanansidhe posted...

It's like a reviver, but if there's two scum and two town left alive scum still wins

Um... two scum left and two town left, scum always wins. lmfao better rethink your bullshit you are spewing.

---

Crescent-Moon posted...

Personally I'd like to see people read 5tar's first day, and compare it to his first day in his recent games.

The only other game where 5tar was that stale and muted day 1 was Phoenix Wright. He was scum in that one.

Didn't 5tar say he didn't really want to play this game but we twisted his arm?

---

Corrik7 posted...

Um... two scum left and two town left, scum always wins. lmfao better rethink your bullshit you are spewing.

Well no, because if he died he would come back, so if there was a vig shot or something it would still be possible for town to win

I don't think I buy this claim but its plausible

---

Yeah, please don't take offense. I just assume everyone on the internet is male. Habit

---

Leanansidhe posted...

I don't think you get it, I die, I flip, and I keep playing. I'm clarifying.

I do get it. if 2 scum left and 2 town left, the game is still over. Game is over when scum controls the lynch. Scum controls the lynch at 2-2 whether they kill you or not.

Like, your rationale for your role literally does not make sense at all. But, it's made up so go figure.

---

Corrik7 posted...

I do get it. if 2 scum left and 2 town left, the game is still over. Game is over when scum controls the lynch. Scum controls the lynch at 2-2 whether they kill you or not.

Like, your rationale for your role literally does not make sense at all. But, it's made up so go figure.

Unless there was a role that stopped that, which this role potentially could.

I buy the role more because of this caveat actually

---

masterplum posted...

Unless there was a role that stopped that, which this role potentially could.

I buy the role more because of this caveat actually

No, plum. There is no buts. Any time there is 2 -2 votes left. Scum wins automatically. Town can never successfully lynch scum. It will no lynch. Even if Town is broken and can both doc save each other night after night, the game is over because scum has won by controlling the lynch.

---

lol scum lea trying to distract town with a bunch of fake claims

---

Leanansidhe posted...

All good!

I'm saying it would be 2-2 and a ghost, not 3-2 town, but whatever

So, you are claiming tree stump and the way tree stump works is.

If you were killed and lived... town would lose even when it is 3 town left and 2 scum left. Because you do not have a vote anymore and scum controls the lynch at 3 town to 2 scum.

You don't understand the mechanics of your fake claim.

---

I don't understand the rationale of Lea claiming this as scum

Like what's her gameplan? Eventually you are going to get lynched to test

---

Corrik7 posted...

So, you are claiming tree stump and the way tree stump works is.

If you were killed and lived... town would lose even when it is 3 town left and 2 scum left. Because you do not have a vote anymore and scum controls the lynch at 3 town to 2 scum.

You don't understand the mechanics of your fake claim.

Corrik. That isn't what she claimed. Her role can be anything. You didn't make it. She didn't claim tree stump

---

Corrik7 posted...

Didn't 5tar say he didn't really want to play this game but we twisted his arm?

I don't recall, if he said such very early on day 1 its possible I could have missed it.

Though it doesn't mean a lot.

I'm still curious about MZero coming in to vote him, then vanishing from the game, and Puns immediately soft defending him after that vote.

Would like to poke MZero about that.

---

masterplum posted...

I don't understand the rationale of Lea claiming this as scum

Like what's her gameplan? Eventually you are going to get lynched to test

Her rationale as scum has always been to claim her way to victory. She claims seemingly impossible things. Enlightened Townie. She claimed day vig when serial day killer because (why would she claim day vig if serial day killer? - She died that game).

Her claims as not town have generally consisted of why would I claim this as scum.

So, she is trying to convince you that she is a stump. You won't remove her from the game but you will remove her vote. So, why lynch her. Which in essence is her defense to not lynch because why would scum do it.

She clearly has zero idea how her supposed role works with game mechanics.

Let me break the Lea lynch down to you simpler though.

Yesterday Lea randomly and very specifically asserted that there was no safe list this game or no flavor split (have to pull the post up to get the specific thing she said but either one means both by extension).

She could only know this has scum, and she could only think to even suggest this is she know this already.

Scare who is undoubtedly town caught this.


---

Crescent-Moon posted...

I don't recall, if he said such very early on day 1 its possible I could have missed it.

Though it doesn't mean a lot.

I'm still curious about MZero coming in to vote him, then vanishing from the game, and Puns immediately soft defending him after that vote.

Would like to poke MZero about that.

Mzero is undoubtedly town also. Along with Uwnim.

---

Leanansidhe posted...

Fine, whatever, I'm a tree stump, you got me, I was trying to make it more interesting. I can't vote after I die, but I'd still rather play from behind the grave so I will continue to try to be lynched and fail.

And Balla is incredibly scum, too bad Red didn't vote and Sultan unvoted without voting Balla, oh well

What the hell is going on

Either Corrik or Lea is scum

---

masterplum posted...

Corrik. That isn't what she claimed. Her role can be anything. You didn't make it. She didn't claim tree stump

Read her post below mine. Yes, she did.

---

masterplum posted...

I don't understand the rationale of Lea claiming this as scum

Like what's her gameplan? Eventually you are going to get lynched to test

This isn't bomb claim, technically there's not a lot of true value to "testing" it.

We just came off a game where Lea claimed town jack as town jack for absolutely no reason at the start if a day though.

---

Corrik7 posted...

Read her post below mine. Yes, she did.

Yeah, but at that point she didn't


---

masterplum posted...

Yeah, but at that point she didn't

You could tell by how she was trying to explain it that she was attempting to claim that. She just didn't understand how the mechanics worked for the role. *hint hint: She isn't it*

And, when she admits she is it... she immediately tries to change the subject to someone else as being scum. Surprising.

---

Corrik7 posted...

Mzero is undoubtedly town also. Along with Uwnim.

MZero has done nothing in the game since his 5tar vote early in topic 2. I haven't seen enough to even try to get a meaningful read on him.

---

How is Scare undoubtedly town?

---

Crescent-Moon posted...

MZero has done nothing in the game since his 5tar vote early in topic 2. I haven't seen enough to even try to get a meaningful read on him.

Well, the reasoning that Mzero appeared to be town may not be valid anymore. He seemed to be claiming bomb defuser day 1. Now that we know Chris gave out a bomb bulletproof and only 1 bomb has gone off and no others, that may not be valid anymore.

However, until the flip last night it was very valid, and I assumed that was our doctor.

---

BallaLeonHall posted...

How is Scare undoubtedly town?

It is predicated on Lea being scum.

Though I thought there was day 2 reasoning also that has slipped my mind beyond that.

---

God, Red not voting to save himself. Why tho. Also Sultan, why invite if you weren't planning on voting someone else?

---

<B>##Vote:Lea</B>

I don't think Stump fits this setup. My theory is there are no vanillas in this game

---