Board 8 > Contest Stats and Discussion - Part 1340

(+) Yeah! (+)

But I do believe that FF 7 R is controversial amont the old fans?

---

It's a remake of a classic game and it doesn't basically copy-paste the story! complaining about the changes in plot and ending were inevitable. I think it's well liked among MOST of those who are playing it, that's the feeling I get from several forums and sites. The average rating here on Gamefaqs is 4.2/5 and on Metacritic user score is 8/10.

---

AxemRedRanger posted...

Nah, Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks.

Hence why I said mainline

---

_SecretSquirrel posted...

The really shocking thing about 2018 is that there seems to be no ceiling on Link that can be observed. Like if Breath of the Wild 2 is another major success, he could end up doubling the next strongest character, who could just be Zelda anyway. Maybe Ganon gets more focus this time around, and he can start beating the lower tier Noble 9ers like Snake and Sonic with little trouble.

I'm still unconvinced that Link much boosted in 2018, if at all. Link vs Ganondorf was already putting up 58% on Cloud vs Sephiroth during the rivalry rumble in 2011 and Link beating Cloud with 60% seems more like Cloud dropping than Link boosting. He also got 68% on Pikachu, but he already got 68% on Mega Man back in 2004 and Pikachu = Mega Man. The rest of his matches were just Zelda SFF fests.

abdou posted...

FFVIIR is the first FF in a long time that is actually liked by most people. It should at least keep Cloud/Tifa in the upper echelon of the characters contests..I am really interested to see how it would do in a games contest as well, it should be stronger than any of the 'weak' FF main games like FF12, FF13 and FF15.

I'd wait until the honeymoon period is over before declaring FFVIIR "the first FF in a long time that is actually liked by most people". FF15 and SS went through this as well when it came out (lots of early threads for both were gushing with praise). Not to mention I've already seen lots of hate starting for FFVIIR on various gaming forums, especially for the ending.

---

Lightning Strikes posted...

Incredibly significant as there is every reason for Life is Strange to have gotten stronger.

... no? Life is Strange was at its peak in 15 and 16. Two underwhelming successors cooled people on the brand, and its tumblr-esque fanbase moved on a long time ago. It has almost certainly gotten weaker.

---

Zelda was definitely on a bandwagon against Link in that final, combined with LAW giving him antivotes, mostly at first.

---

Also who was saying Europe was gonna carry FFXV? Big whoops there

---

Safer_777 posted...

But I do believe that FF 7 R is controversial amont the old fans?

Nah, it's controversial among the people who looked up spoilers ahead of time and thought some of the changes were stupid.

Almost everyone I've seen who's actually been playing the game seems to like it a lot.
---

I like how someone keeps tricking the server into thinking they're from North Korea.

---

darn it FFXV put this match away and stop giving up random 25 vote cuts
---

MechanicalWall posted...

Also who was saying Europe was gonna carry FFXV? Big whoops there

i mean europe has been known to carry FF a lot

but it seems even XV is hated in Sonylands

---

BlAcK TuRtLe posted...

Hence why I said mainline

Stuff like Tri Force Heroes, Links Crossbow Training, or Four Swords or whatever can probably be written off as side games. However, the DS Zeldas are some pretty Zelda-y Zelda games and I dont think it makes sense to say theyre not mainline just because theyre portable or not good. Its not like most of series is numbered or has a meaningful overarching plot to let us make these distinctions. And Ive never heard of anyone not willing to grant Links Awakening main series status.

---

Nintendo definitely considers Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks main games. Pretty sure anything that got propped up in the Hyrule Historia timeline is considered a 'main game'.

---

SS is still liked. Weak Zelda !=bad game. If anything the fact that SS is low on the totem pole shows the standard to which that franchise is held!

---

it has been reshared in r/hollowknightmemes 20 minutes ago

---

abdou posted...

FFVIIR is the first FF in a long time that is actually liked by most people. It should at least keep Cloud/Tifa in the upper echelon of the characters contests..I am really interested to see how it would do in a games contest as well, it should be stronger than any of the 'weak' FF main games like FF12, FF13 and FF15.

Maybe Cloud can come back to beating Link in the night vote again!

(and losing anyway)

Hollow Knight's actually giving FF15 a battle! Go, lil Knight, go!

Never thought it'd even have a chance. (Kind of shows the overall flaws with a poll-based bracket but, hey, it's good drama).

Is HK that strong or FF15 that weak?

---

Yes.

---

How many on this board are against rallies?

I wasn't a fan of how they interfered with the 2013 and 2015 contests, but telling people not to vote in our contests is even more ridiculous. Those two contests were more exciting than 2018 was anyway.

---

Nah, 2018 was way better than 2013.

---

To each their own, but 2018 didn't really have any standout moments. I basically remember everything but Nintendo doing poorly.

---

All I remember from 2013 was Pokemon and Draven dominating everything

A big no thanks from me

---

There was also Vivi knocking out Mario which was interesting to say the least.

I don't know.

---

More seriously, 2016 wasn't a great year for games being strong here:

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/poll/6575-best-of-2016-game-of-the-year-final-vote

FF15 ended up winning GotY here, but it did lose this poll to a Pokemon game before doing that so that'll question its ceiling in a contest. We also saw Uncharted 4 drop its match again Mario Kart 8 easily.

If we go back one poll to the first overall GotY that year:

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/poll/6574-best-of-2016-game-of-the-year

I wasn't impressed with Overwatch's win over Death Stranding. DOOM crushed INSIDE and Stardew Valley smacked up Destiny, definitely, but those matches might not mean that much. We'll learn more about Overwatch/DOOM/SV when they face Xenoblade/REmake 2/SMG2 this round.

Meanwhile, Hollow Knight's exceeding expectations and is another game from 2017 that has been looking good in the meanwhile, however, so it's impressing me more than FF15 is failing me.

---

2018 had, just from my memory:

• Link putting his greatest results ever
• Zelda suddenly a top 5
• Cloud saving the contest from a Nintendo vs Nintendo finals
• Pikachu breaking the N9 for real this time (and then being defeated by MM in Loser's Bracket)
• Samus losing to Mario, coming back stronger in Losers and giving us the closet finish in the contest
• Porn Rally FEAR, and Tifa
• Tifa vs MMX vs Luigi gauntlet
• Revenge against Draven
• Sans losing to Pac Man
• Sora and Riku signaling the beginning of KH3's suckiness
• Donkey Kong winning two consecutive upsets
• Geralt winning 3 debated matches in a run, all with comebacks
• 2B also winning difficult matches and showing modern games can be legit
• Alucard's dream run
• Mewtwo being a fraud
• Terra exposing Charizard in a match nobody thought would be close
• Shepard being exposed by freaking K. Rool
• Noctis being utterly destroyed by a glove
• Kirby crushing all the field then losing to Bowser on what may or may not have been rSSF
• Monika putting the whole board into panic for weeks then getting rekt by Wario

I've said it a million times, but do NOT look at 2017 as reflective of Hollow Knight. The consoles ports mattered a LOT for that game.

---

2018 had a ton of super close matches between top 20 level characters...i think more than any other contest potentially?

Yeah 2018 was when the gap between the N9 and the rest disappeared for good, so we now have like 15 elite characters who can challenge one another, right below a Noble Six.

Link

Cloud
Mario
Samus
Zelda
Snake

Crono
Sonic
Mega Man
Sephiroth
Pikachu
Alucard
Luigi
Tifa
MMX
Ganondorf
Bowser
Kirby
Vivi

Man I want rallies?

---

I assume that last tier isn't meant to be in order!

---

HaRRicH posted...

More seriously, 2016 wasn't a great year for games being strong here:

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/poll/6575-best-of-2016-game-of-the-year-final-vote

FF15 ended up winning GotY here, but it did lose this poll to a Pokemon game before doing that so that'll question its ceiling in a contest. We also saw Uncharted 4 drop its match again Mario Kart 8 easily.

If we go back one poll to the first overall GotY that year:

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/poll/6574-best-of-2016-game-of-the-year

I wasn't impressed with Overwatch's win over Death Stranding. DOOM crushed INSIDE and Stardew Valley smacked up Destiny, definitely, but those matches might not mean that much. We'll learn more about Overwatch/DOOM/SV when they face Xenoblade/REmake 2/SMG2 this round.

Meanwhile, Hollow Knight's exceeding expectations and is another game from 2017 that has been looking good in the meanwhile, however, so it's impressing me more than FF15 is failing me.

2016 also has Dark Souls III, which didn't even make the GotY polls.

---

ZeldaTPLink posted...

Pikachu breaking the N9 for real this time (and then being defeated by MM in Loser's Bracket)

Is winning due to registered user bonus more real than winning in a 12 hour match?

I seem to recall that being debated, but then Zelda and Tifa broke it for good.

---

Safer_777 posted...

Is HK that strong or FF15 that weak?

its both.

---

Now that round 1 is done I'm happy to see that I managed to get 58 points total.

Most Surprising Eliminations
The Walking Dead: A Telltale Games Series
Undertale
Dragon Age: Inquisition

Eliminations I was 50/50 on
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth
Sid Meier's Civilization V
Celeste

---

Crono/Mega Man/Pikachu > Sonic/Sephiroth/Tifa/MMX > Luigi/Bowser/Yoshi/Kirby/Ganondorf > Vivi/Alucard/Auron/Zero imo

---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/691087-playstation-4/78571693

it's weird seeing contest discussion on another board, especially the ps4 one

---

Oh yeah Zelda going on a tear. Felt like we maybe should have seen it coming considering.

I remember idiotically picking Vivi to win his division, completely forgetting Breath of the Wild is a thing.

---

LinkMarioSamus posted...

Oh yeah Zelda going on a tear. Felt like we maybe should have seen it coming considering.

I remember idiotically picking Vivi to win his division, completely forgetting Breath of the Wild is a thing.

literally no one could have predicted Zelda becoming a Noble Nine killer

and Vivi got 48% on Ganondorf, that wasn't a bad pick
---

ZenOfThunder posted...

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/691087-playstation-4/78571693

it's weird seeing contest discussion on another board, especially the ps4 one

It happens all the time lmao. Everyday there's at least one or two

A memorable one recently was the Horizon vs Fortnite match

---

2018 definitely had loads of memorable moments. Like Zelda caving Squalls face in despite bring the underdog. Or Zelda narrowly beating Snake. Or Zelda blowing past Sonic. Or Zelda beating Matio. Or Zelda leading Link. I detect a theme!

Its the goat contest run because it was all unrallied. Tifa vs. Mega Man X was an all-timer too.

---

Lightning Strikes posted...

2018 definitely had loads of memorable moments. Like Zelda caving Squalls face in despite bring the underdog. Or Zelda narrowly beating Snake. Or Zelda blowing past Sonic. Or Zelda beating Matio. Or Zelda leading Link. I detect a theme!

Its the goat contest run because it was all unrallied. Tifa vs. Mega Man X was an all-timer too.

Zelda's run was unreal. I knew she'd beat Squall (which pained me because Squall's my all-time fave), but never imagined she'd rip through the N9ers she encountered.

---

Cloud getting revenge on Mario 16 years later was pretty amazing too!

---

Kotetsu534 posted...

Cloud getting revenge on Mario 16 years later was pretty amazing too!

The original Mario vs Cloud was an all-time classic. I still remember everyone losing their minds because it was the day Mario Sunshine came out on the West Coast (us East Coasters had to wait till the next day) and all the Mario fans on Board 8 were hoping people would get stuck in Sunshine, come to GFAQs, and vote.

What a match. I'd only rank CT/LttP above it.

---

2018 was a crazy situation where Cloud impressed by still being the #2 guy in this site while Mario disappointed by failing to prove himself after his 2013 loss to Vivi by losing in two matches where he was favored in.

Cloud impressing and Mario disappointing at GameFAQs polls in 2018? Never thought something like that could happen.

Lightning Strikes posted...

Its the goat contest run because it was all unrallied. Tifa vs. Mega Man X was an all-timer too.

I mean, should these two sentences be together? Tifa was pretty uniquely rallied.

---

I think when most people say they don't want rallies, they mean contest breaking ones.

Not to mention MMX was rallying just as hard. He just doesn't have as good of porn.

---

That's fair.

---

Leonhart4 posted...

I think when most people say they don't want rallies, they mean contest breaking ones.

Exactly. Vivi > Mario was like the best contest result we've ever had.

---

plasmabeam posted...

What a match. I'd only rank CT/LttP above it.

Ah man, I remember cheating for CT in my high school's computer lab. I was an anti-Square guy back then, but it's always been BRACKET LOVE first.

---