Board 8 > Elden Ring Mafia Topic 3: WIFOM's Great Rune

(+) Yeah! (+)

Actually I'm going to go a step further, because Marth's assessment is flat out wrong.

I've called both Corrik and Scare town. Both Corrik and Scare have done little to nothing today but shade me.

Scare always attacks me early game on bad personal meta that usually contradicts previous personal meta he's used.

My gut feeling is it's coming from bad town here, as it usually is.

Panthera posted...

This is trying too hard to avoid committing. It goes without saying that you're open to revisiting your reads as the day progresses in the early hours of day 1, no one knows anything with 100% certainty yet. Pointing it out doesn't do much besides give you an out if questioned about voting one of them later.

##Vote: Chang

I 100% understand this vote but as someone who was very suspicious of chang last game this is just how he talks. He doesn't commit and doesn't vote too often. He could be mimicking his town game, and fair, but this kind of tell isn't effective with him.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Crescent. All I asked is do you want to be confirmed?

I would have literally immediately unvoted had she said no and dropped the issue entirely. It was a layup, and all I got was I wont play with you. I dont think that attitude should be in games at all, imo.

I'm just curious how an unlynchable claim made you instantly drop all suspicion on her. Why did you not consider scenarios like reverse psychology to get a good mafia action in or something?

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I 100% understand this vote but as someone who was very suspicious of chang last game this is just how he talks. He doesn't commit and doesn't vote too often. He could be mimicking his town game, and fair, but this kind of tell isn't effective with him.

I'm almost positive someone else said something just like this, but I have no idea who.

I hate to say it since it will make Corrik happier
But there is that paranoid part of me deep down that worries that Crescent and Chris planned this ahead of time and that still wants to test Crescent.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Actually I'm going to go a step further, because Marth's assessment is flat out wrong.

I've called both Corrik and Scare town. Both Corrik and Scare have done little to nothing today but shade me.

Scare always attacks me early game on bad personal meta that usually contradicts previous personal meta he's used.

My gut feeling is it's coming from bad town here, as it usually is.

I'm not saying you scum read EVERYONE that suspects you or votes you.

htaeD posted...

I hate to say it since it will make Corrik happier
But there is that paranoid part of me deep down that worries that Crescent and Chris planned this ahead of time and that still wants to test Crescent.

Death passes the vibe check

UnderUrMattress posted...

I'm not saying you scum read EVERYONE that suspects you or votes you.

You do realize I scumread Isquen before he voted me? It was just the vote that made it stronger

Ulti is the only person I've actually directly called scum based on the way he has pursued me. What MZero did that bugged me had nothing to do with my lynch.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Death passes the vibe check

Death definitely passes the vibe check, I agree.

Vibe Check list so far:

Day 1 pass (this is not permission if I die tonight to go 'chris they were for sure town', lists die every eod and then you re-sort the next day. CONSTANT VIGILANCE)
Crescent
changmas
death

not lynching day 1 lol
corrik

did not pass

Ulti

Who else should I read?

htaeD posted...

I hate to say it since it will make Corrik happier
But there is that paranoid part of me deep down that worries that Crescent and Chris planned this ahead of time and that still wants to test Crescent.

Oh we are definitely lynching Crescent today

htaeD posted...

I hate to say it since it will make Corrik happier
But there is that paranoid part of me deep down that worries that Crescent and Chris planned this ahead of time and that still wants to test Crescent.

What

Chris literally just subbed in lmao

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Ben keep up we've already moved on

Okay it is hard to keep up with the numbr of posts but i just got caught up to this page and see that you already said what i just said.

Whatever you are, it's nice to have someone in the game who isnt a boring confirm the role andy

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Vibe Check list so far:

Day 1 pass (this is not permission if I die tonight to go 'chris they were for sure town', lists die every eod and then you re-sort the next day. CONSTANT VIGILANCE)
Crescent
changmas
death

not lynching day 1 lol
corrik

did not pass

Ulti

Who else should I read?

Read Isquen and compare his play this game to his play in FFXIV.

If anyone can pick up on something I may have missed, you'll probably be that person.

UnderUrMattress posted...

What

Chris literally just subbed in lmao

Technically he was aware of subbing in for a while now
But I suppose timezones play a part here to alleviate some paranoia

UnderUrMattress posted...

What

Chris literally just subbed in lmao

I was quiet for 3 hours after subbing in. Plenty of time for scum chris to ruin your day. Death gets it

(I was asleep but CONSTANT VIGILANCE)

UnderUrMattress posted...

What

Chris literally just subbed in lmao

I technically claimed only after he replaced. The paranoid is understandable. Death is also just town anyway.

I only hinted that I was going to do something spicy last night. I didn't say what.

I have three working scenarios atm.

Chris scum
Ulti scum
Crescent scum

Chris scum makes Crescent town
Likely with igcd mattress and Chang scum

Ulti scum makes Chris town and mattress town

Crescent scum ulti town
Bunch of newbies scum and/or red

Yeah I don't think Death is scum, I just think it's a batty tinfoil.

Speaking of Batty, where is Bat?

But anyway, the rational part of Death is telling the paranoid part it's stupid because it'd be a senseless gambit for absolutely no reason.

I simply don't believe scum Death has what it takes to make that post. Scum Death is going to shy away from that kind of post.

Panthera and death are my bois.

oh red claimed miller. Yeah he's probably fine, he's not the type to draw any attention to himself as scum.

Red claiming miller gave me a town lean on him, but it sure would be nice if he'd give us more content.

content from red day 1 is often times asking for a bridge too far. I tried last game and he lynched me like a jerk

Scum red generally makes excuses to not stuff. Town red generally doesn't give a fuck

Red got pissy at me for nagging at him so that checks out.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Fun fact: we played a few games on the now extinct forum mafia board. You had a different username at the time though. You got modkilled in one of the games lol.

That's awesome lol. I remember your username just not the way you played.

I just assumed red wanted to get content the easy way

Also we've had an insane spread of votes. Like 11 different people have been voted on at some point today.

Yeah i pulled an all nighter yesterday(Night before last) and now I'm sleepy for non mafia reasons this time.

it's fine red can have the day off. Just be around for deadline

Marth, I would like to know where you got the idea of me countersuspecting the people who have been calling me scum from, especially given how I've repeatedly called Corrik town.

I want a source.

Crescent your 262 in topic one is a bad post btw. You give newbies way more rope to hang themselves than two early posts. Now it might be hard to read him since he will be defensive.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Also we've had an insane spread of votes. Like 11 different people have been voted on at some point today.

And none are me!

Which is crazy because I usually have to fight a bandwagon d1. It's been nice.

Side note about vibe checks to Chris:

Does scum Sultan immediately respond to MZero and Marth reappearing out of the either to vote me by recognizing I'm being voted on too quickly and unvoting?

Because I don't think he does this if he is scum.

UnderUrMattress posted...

And none are me!

Which is crazy because I usually have to fight a bandwagon d1. It's been nice.

*tilts head* why would you say this

I'll be at baseball i think but I'll be around. In AZ to catch a couple ST games. Plans got thrashed around for my cat.

I'm too old to do this even after sleep everything is tired and my legs are made of cramps.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Crescent your 262 in topic one is a bad post btw. You give newbies way more rope to hang themselves than two early posts. Now it might be hard to read him since he will be defensive.

I don't remember which post 282 was offhand. I just remember thinking "If I get a quick countervote, my scum read gets way stronger".

I freely admit I may have played this a little TOO loosely.

Crescent I... ergh you botched this Isquen stuff so hard.

You are claiming Isquen was summoned when we all knew (well I would have if I had been there) that he was due to come back from work. Like maybe he is scum but that's such a hard tunnel asap on a newbie.

And by this I mean the game in general.

I should've probably given Isquen more rope to hang himself with, like I did with Ulti last night.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Marth, I would like to know where you got the idea of me countersuspecting the people who have been calling me scum from, especially given how I've repeatedly called Corrik town.

I want a source.

What i mean is that people vote you and even if you had suspicion prior to that, you keep it.

But like when I voted you it made you drop your town lean on me.

So like that left Isquen, Ulti, MZero which was like, half of your bw, and then me which wasn't a full sr but yeah.

It's trivial atp.

UltimaterializerX posted...

##Unvote
##Vote: Marth
##Unvote
##Vote: Chang

NOOOOOO

marth passes day 1 vibe check

MZero did not vote me because he thought I was scum. His vote just reminded me I didn't like a previous interaction I had with him.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Crescent I... ergh you botched this Isquen stuff so hard.

You are claiming Isquen was summoned when we all knew (well I would have if I had been there) that he was due to come back from work. Like maybe he is scum but that's such a hard tunnel asap on a newbie.

I have a godly role that maaaaaaay have gotten to my head a bit.

Crescent-Moon posted...

MZero did not vote me because he thought I was scum. His vote just reminded me I didn't like a previous interaction I had with him.

Fair enough

I assume Bat is your biggest suspect that hasn't voted you at some point today?

godly roles are when you should use more prudence to lead town in a good manner, Crescent. It is the difference between good and great town play.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Fair enough

I assume Bat is your biggest suspect that hasn't voted you at some point today?

This would still be correct.