Board 8 > Psych Mafia Topic 2: I'm not inclined to resign to maturity. If it's all right..

(+) Yeah! (+)

masterplum posted...

What the hell does this mean

My bad plum typing to fast on phone

Host did not say corrik was town

Corrik was hidden under the name shape.

Corrik when I came in said he was the 3rd party.

Corrik when he fully claimed claimed town.

corrik could be some sort of scum role that neighbors someone. That's been done.

anyway we may, we solve, we have at least one more night of tracker info. cool beans

Ok, so you were kidnapped by a role that didn't indicate who it was.

I need a full claim from Corrik. Leaning towards third party him

I'll add this 9 thought corrik might have accidentally been telling the truth about flavor based off what I know about the show and Psyvh the movie and could make sense as town.

But the only thing that makes me concerned is he claims not to have gotten a pinapple

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

I'll add this 9 thought corrik might have accidentally been telling the truth about flavor based off what I know about the show and Psyvh the movie and could make sense as town.

so then it also makes sense as scum?

And you give pineapples and he received none.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

This is true I was supposed to returb

When were you supposed to return? Because Day 2 began with Crescent-Moon saying you were missing.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

But the only thing that makes me concerned is he claims not to have gotten a pinapple

That is what makes you concerned by getting kidnapped by someone who could choose not to reveal their name huh

masterplum posted...

Ok, so you were kidnapped by a role that didn't indicate who it was.

I need a full claim from Corrik. Leaning towards third party him

I am basically dayvig.

Corrik's probably lying about the Pineapple because Sultan is clearly trythful here and has no reason to lie about that aspect. And Corrik could just be trying to test him. What's important is -

Sultan, was it host confirmed that Corrik had the option to kill or spare your life?

Seriously why the hell did this have to be corrik, literally the only person who I conceivably see claiming third party as town for no real reason.

I kind of could see this being a town role. It has town potential

I am fine with corrik for the day

Corrik7 posted...

I am basically dayvig.

##Vote:Corrik

No, I want a real full claim. There are things that don't add up

Sultan did not give a pineapple to me. But, if I felt he was scum, I would have killed him. So it's moot.

Corrik7 posted...

Sultan did not give a pineapple to me. But, if I felt he was scum, I would have killed him. So it's moot.

These two statements feel mutually incompatible

masterplum posted...

##Vote:Corrik

No, I want a real full claim. There are things that don't add up

I gave my claim to Sultan. If he chooses not to reveal it, then so be it.

Host said nothing other than I could only post in that chat and i was not dead. And we had a time limit on our chat before it closed

Corrik7 posted...

Sultan did not give a pineapple to me. But, if I felt he was scum, I would have killed him. So it's moot.

did you say yet why you chose Sultan?

Corrik7 posted...

I gave my claim to Sultan. If he chooses not to reveal it, then so be it.

And I can vote for you, and if you choose not to reveal it I can not unvote you

masterplum posted...

And I can vote for you, and if you choose not to reveal it I can not unvote you

You can do whatever you want to do.

Obellisk posted...

did you say yet why you chose Sultan?

I told him why also. If he doesn't want to reveal it, then so be it. It has more weight coming from him I am sure.

Cool, going to bed. If you want to end day early to keep up the trend I won't stop you.

...

I lied

##Unvote

Obellisk posted...

did kidnapping Sultan have any additional effects? if he has been shot would you have "saved" him from that?

no, no. If he had been shot, the power wouldn't have happened and it could have been used a different night.

I want to go to bed but I am bothered

Scenario 1: Nobody is lying

Ben: Doc
Chris Saved by Doc
Ranagrade: tracker
Corrik: Ridiculously weird kidnapper role

Left over:

1. IGCD

2. SBell

3. Sultan

4. Ulti

What scum team blind fires into Chris N1? IGCD?

So if I got this right. You can kidnap a person for a limited amount of time and choose to kill them or they return to the game.

And you decided to let Sultan live thus surrendering your big shot?

I can't believe I am doing this....

But supposing Corrik is a town hostage interrogator, I could see him initially claiming third party as a ruse to try to deduce if the person he interrogated is town or scum.

I realized this and it made me immediately back pedal. That's plausible

Sultan not being forthcoming about the chat details is a bit odd, and I find it weird.

That said, he said he gave me a pineapple and I checked... and double checked... and triple checked... and it was mentioned nowhere.

He also said he was Pineapple Vendor.

I said what's your flavor. He said Pineapple Vendor. I said okay what is your role. He said Pineapple Vendor.

I said okay so your role is Pineapple Vendor Town Pineapple Vendor?

He said yes. I felt this was odd.

I knew day 1 he wanted to claim and he wanted to be targeted night 1, so I assumed either A. His role wasn't what he was saying and he was a watcher of some sort. Or B. He is a delayed PGO of some sort (possibly serial killer) who gives our grenades to people who visit him and he can choose when to detonate them.

All I can say for sure is... I was not informed I was given a pineapple.

Yeah that is the one thing that absolutely doesn't track Corrik

Sultan claimed to give you a pineapple and yet you got no pineapple.

Why the hell would you let him go instead of killing him?

The motivations for Corrik picking sultan if he was scum kidnapper really don't make any sense so he's probably town.

So why did you let him go then?

PunishedBen posted...

The motivations for Corrik picking sultan if he was scum kidnapper really don't make any sense so he's probably not mafia.

fixed that for you

Obellisk posted...

So if I got this right. You can kidnap a person for a limited amount of time and choose to kill them or they return to the game.

And you decided to let Sultan live thus surrendering your big shot?

It would have made sense for sultan to divulge this and not me... but I told him I realized I made a mistake at the beginning of day 2 because I chose him because I thought he wasn't on the tidus lynch and that he was. That I was kinda sure he was town so I was gonna release him regardless. I released him at the bare minimum time. We discussed who we thought might be scum on the Tidus lynch, he also pointed to post 156 today which is the post that I not him pointed out against Ben from Day 1.

I was actually going to maybe just shoot him anyways because his role doesn't match up to what he said it should do and because it didn't seem like a loss for town if he died, but I realized that would make you guys think I was scum... so I didn't. Though before I decided for sure what to do there, apparently me telling Sultan I was going to release him made the chat vanish before it's time was up when I was still deliberating and never officially chose to release him but heyyyy.

I'm starting to think maybe Corrik and Sultan are both scum, with Corrik having been some kind of mafia recruiter.

For the record, a Tidus/Sultan/IGCD scum team would both be

A. Hilariously unlucky
B. One of the only combination of teams I could come up with that would think shooting Chris N1 with a normal shot is a good idea.

masterplum posted...

I want to go to bed but I am bothered

Scenario 1: Nobody is lying

Ben: Doc
Chris Saved by Doc
Ranagrade: tracker
Corrik: Ridiculously weird kidnapper role

Left over:

1. IGCD

2. SBell

3. Sultan

4. Ulti

What scum team blind fires into Chris N1? IGCD?

Probably just a risky play that you want to go for. I mean I almost didn't protect Chris night 1 because I was like "Well who the hell would shoot him night 1. I need to be big brain here and go for the second choice. "

But I thought scum might think the same thing and it looks like they did!

wtf why am I starting to believe Corrik.

And since Sultan won't do the obvious thing of reveal my role like I told him to do to confirm our chat today... I will. And, he can't say he forgot what it was because he made a big deal about eaed liking the show a lot and it being some John Cena shit or something from the movie and I was like oh I thought this flavor was some anime nonsense.

Ewan O'Hara, TOWN Classified

Ok we absolutely are not lynching Corrik

The point I'm stuck on is...

If Corrik was scum or a third party.... there is no way in hell he releases sultan right?

masterplum posted...

The point I'm stuck on is...

If Corrik was scum or a third party.... there is no way in hell he releases sultan right?

I think there is a greater chance infinitely that Sultan is scum or 3rd party. Pineapple is a common term for Grenade I believe.

masterplum posted...

The point I'm stuck on is...

If Corrik was scum or a third party.... there is no way in hell he releases sultan right?

third party maybe? scum, no way.

Obellisk posted...

third party maybe? scum, no way.

Even if he is third party, why leave a witness who knows it was him?

ya know what, especially with the cop dead, why let Sultan live.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

##Vote: Corrik

only vote on the cop that wasn't on the roleblocker.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Oh shit.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

##Unvote
##Vote:Corrik

Kinda liking an IGCD Lynch

But, I didn't kill him and here he is so that is that.

And, yes, I started the chat saying I was third party and I could choose to join his team. I had 3 options I told him. 1. To kill him outright. 2. Release him. or 3. If I correctly had his alignment and chose to join I would join his team or we both die if I was wrong on the alignment.

I said it was like the game where you put your hand in the box and you choose to share or take it for yourself basically.

I put my vote down on Death and said the day might end soon so he had to hurry and tell me what he is. He said some nonsensical pineapple vendor stuff, which I verified I did not get at any point, and I just decided him being on Tidus and the flip had to be good enough for letting him live for now and assumed he was just lying about his role for whatever reason. We talked about some stuff in the game from day 1... i asked if there was anything else he wanted to talk about and the chat vanished.

Obellisk posted...

ya know what, especially with the cop dead, why let Sultan live.

I could have just not revealed my name ever.