Board 8 > Nickelodeon Mafia Topic 4- Toons all day long

(+) Yeah! (+)

htaeD posted...

When was that?

This game

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/6/0/7/AAVaiKAADYNn.jpg

What a bunch of jokers
...

We already had a Xenoblade Mafia didnt we?

PunishedBen posted...

Hey Tidus what information were you looking to get out of lynching me day1?

If you were scum, it would increase the chances of ulti and lea being scum, if not, then it's probably lower.

htaeD posted...

What a bunch of jokers
...

We already had a Xenoblade Mafia didnt we?

Speaking of xenoblade, I'm interested in the series now solely due to shulk being awesome in smash ultimate

Tidus, where do you keep going to?

PunishedBen posted...

True and real

Dont get me wrong, my desire to kill Sheep still burns strong. I also do not think Tidus has anything towny going for him besides the "scan"

I think this contradicts a point you made near the beginning of my entrance

htaeD posted...

Tidus, where do you keep going to?

I don't want to mislead town with how new I am with mafia and how I'm confirmed town

I do not like the idea of lynching the four people in the "unconnected" part of Red's list.

Let's put this simply: does anyone genuinely believe it's more likely that either myself or Kirby is Scum than Plum is? Or hell, more likely Scum than Tidus? Cause if I had to choose right now, I'd put odds on Tidus being Scum over Kirby.

Also, I'm pretty sure Plum being Town hard requires Lea to be scum, unless we're going down an IGCD/Red conspiracy rabbit hole. Since I very much hope everyone sensible has long ruled that out... we should do the thing I have spent most of the game saying we should do.

##Vote: Plum

TidusOfTheX posted...

I don't want to mislead town with how new I am with mafia and how I'm confirmed town

Okay, let's step back from the misleading Town thing for a second. There's a lot of strong players here, and they will call you out if you have an abysmal read.

Who is Scum, Tidus?

TidusOfTheX posted...

I think this contradicts a point you made near the beginning of my entrance

Was a typo since i was replying to Sheep. Should have been "Plum"

Sheep007 posted...

Okay, let's step back from the misleading Town thing for a second. There's a lot of strong players here, and they will call you out if you have an abysmal read.

Who is Scum, Tidus?

Probably Ben. It's not plum since I know for a fact that he's not lying about me being town.

PunishedBen posted...

Was a typo since i was replying to Sheep. Should have been "Plum"

Not that part

TidusOfTheX posted...

Probably Ben. It's not plum since I know for a fact that he's not lying about me being town.

Have you followed the game at all?

TidusOfTheX posted...

Probably Ben. It's not plum since I know for a fact that he's not lying about me being town.

This feels a bit more nave than a player should be at this point.

Yeah, I'm not satisfied at all with Tidus's posts.

Hence why we should kill Plum and see if Tidus's immunity as "confirmed" Town is actually valid or not. I'm with Sheep here.

TidusOfTheX posted...

Probably Ben. It's not plum since I know for a fact that he's not lying about me being town.

Two (actually, three) things.

Ben being Scum probably requires IGCD to be Scum as well. Do you think that is the case? Have you actually been reading the game? And who else do you think is Scum? There's probably four of them and I would appreciate it if you had more than one poorly thought out suspect.

Scum are, believe it or not, capable of lying!

I hate that this post is dumbtelling so hard it's making me think Tidus is Town

TidusOfTheX posted...

Not that part

Oh. Well if i called you towny I would be happy to be reminded why.

TidusOfTheX posted...

Probably Ben. It's not plum since I know for a fact that he's not lying about me being town.

I feel like there was a wink and a twirl of tidus's mustache after he said this.

PunishedBen posted...

Conclusion?

this post bothers me. the conclusion is there. you don't need to say conclusion.

there's no way that post would end in "so I think red is town".

like, what was your end game with that post?

I'm gonna be on mobile and would rather not make the trek to The Site right now, but can anyone remember if Tidus was acting as oblivious in Fire Emblem Awakening Mafia? I always suck at figuring out when dumbtelling is being faked, but I wanna check what Tidus acted like in earlier games in comparison.

Obellisk posted...

this post bothers me. the conclusion is there. you don't need to say conclusion.

there's no way that post would end in "so I think red is town".

like, what was your end game with that post?

To hear your conclusion.

You said you've never seen Red so active and then left it at that. Couldn't tell if that was supposed to mean you scum read him or town read him, or if anything else of his has swayed you either way

Well I checked the whole end of day2 situation and of the people who even humored lynching Plum over DYL I like Ben the most for already given reasons.
Sheep is after that since he at least established his Plumhatred, but he did not seem to question his vote as much as Ben did for a while.
Kirby just seemed to be in his usual not too serious mood. But looking back Plum was so clearly giddy about Kirby possibly going after Ben instead. As was DYL. And that is making me like Kirby more since I dont know if scum would incite such a reaction from scum.

Sbell was also being more jokey than involved. But he did say he didnt like DYLs claim and didnt vote anyone else.

Of course if Plum flips scum, all of this analyzing could be moot anyway. Besides maybe in the event of plumscum being a less powerful role for scum.

PunishedBen posted...

You said you've never seen Red so active and then left it at that. Couldn't tell if that was supposed to mean you scum read him or town read him, or if anything else of his has swayed you either way

Apparently no one remembers even a little bit of the book of scum red.

Obellisk posted...

this post bothers me. the conclusion is there. you don't need to say conclusion.

there's no way that post would end in "so I think red is town".

like, what was your end game with that post?

Never mind I see what you were trying to say now. Just had to read it again

Leafeon13N posted...

Apparently no one remembers even a little bit of the book of scum red.

If it's anything like the Book of boba Fett then you are actually much nicer as scum than anyone remembers.

PunishedBen posted...

If it's anything like the Book of boba Fett then you are actually much nicer as scum than anyone remembers.

Probably a little bit.

Sheep007 posted...

I'm gonna be on mobile and would rather not make the trek to The Site right now, but can anyone remember if Tidus was acting as oblivious in Fire Emblem Awakening Mafia? I always suck at figuring out when dumbtelling is being faked, but I wanna check what Tidus acted like in earlier games in comparison.

Honestly just from a couple of pages I feel like Tidus was a lot sharper in that game. He even put a vote down that guy. He also admitted when he didnt have much to say and wanted to improve.

Maybe we should just threaten him with a good ol' time

##Vote: Plum

We have a fair few people that haven't said a lot or haven't said a lot in awhile.

Well ill say this much...

##Unvote
##Vote: Plum

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


... This is gonna be my new reputation now, won't it? >.<

But I imagine whoever is scum is royally pissed that IGCD wasn't just an easy kill even after lynching the doctor D1. I just hope IGCD's wasted scan on Ben doesn't come back to bite us.

Leafeon13N posted...

We have a fair few people that haven't said a lot or haven't said a lot in awhile.

I've hardly been available today, my apologies.

Awaiting Plum...

Man, I know it's a Friday night but I was expecting something from Plum.

Okay, caught up.

Sorry to hear about your daughter's ankle, IGCD, and that your show bombed Lea. I have some bad news too: My 99 y/o grandmother passed yesterday morning (I haven't really wanted to talk about it, just distract myself) so that's partly why I haven't been as present. Some of you may recall she had a stroke a month ago... gonna miss her. The other part was that today we were celebrating my sister's graduation as a family (a month after the fact) at one of the best restaurants in the state, an hour away. Busy busy.

Red and IGCD aren't necessarily aligned the same. Red could definitely be scum given how defensive he got and how he seemed desperate to divert the lynch. IGCD... I really doubt it. If Red is scum, he's trying to create a mislynch on IGCD. Unless I'm missing something. This seems in line with him calling the DYL lynch "boring" (which is not a good look for him now).

I still wanna wait and see if Plum has anything to say before I vote again.

What do you reckon the explanation for the lack of kill last night is, if not Red's save, BCT?

htaeD posted...

Honestly just from a couple of pages I feel like Tidus was a lot sharper in that game. He even put a vote down that guy. He also admitted when he didnt have much to say and wanted to improve.

Agreed, but I also think he was impotent in Kingmaker Mafia, when he rolled Cop and got himself killed D2 because it contradicted his earlier statements. I don't know if this is the natural reaction to being slaughtered two games in a row, but I'm struggling to figure out anything from what he does have. It's a shame, because although he wasn't Town MVP or anything in FE:A, he was fun to have in the game and genuinely tried, which is all anyone can ask of a new player. This is just kinda sad.

Sheep007 posted...

What do you reckon the explanation for the lack of kill last night is, if not Red's save, BCT?

Red's save is a possibility. There's also the thought that scum was threatened by Lea and shot her to test her ability, and then when she didn't die, had Red claim backup doc save in an effort to clear him.

Not sure why scum would keep IGCD alive though, and like I said I'm pretty sure he's town unless I'm missing something.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Red and IGCD aren't necessarily aligned the same. Red could definitely be scum given how defensive he got and how he seemed desperate to divert the lynch. IGCD... I really doubt it. If Red is scum, he's trying to create a mislynch on IGCD. Unless I'm missing something. This seems in line with him calling the DYL lynch "boring" (which is not a good look for him now).

The answer to if you are missing something: yes.

Leafeon13N posted...

The answer to if you are missing something: yes.

Please elaborate.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Please elaborate.

Your conclusions are ludicrous. I could contemplate for a million years and never get to a point where somehow i could be setting up an igcd mislynch.

Ah yes it's ludicrous to think there's any way Red is scum just like it was ludicrous to think Chris was anything but 3rd party serial killer last game

So after Plum we kill Tidus and then the last one is probably Death or Sbell and we win yay

Yeahh.... that's not working for me, Red. You can't just say my conclusions suck without proper rebuttal. You are again stonewalling in order to push what you want, much like you tried to with protecting DYL or seeding doubt about Ulti/IGCD. Now you're outright denying it.

##Vote:Red

What led you to the conclusion that Red is trying to intentionally get a town IGCD lynched by his actions?

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Yeahh.... that's not working for me, Red. You can't just say my conclusions suck without proper rebuttal.

The conclusion literally makesno sense when I'm telling you igcd is super confirmed town.