Board 8 > Alcohol topic 3 can drink all day if you dont start in the morning

(+) Yeah! (+)

Invalid game, totally fair, scum only needed one mislynch to win. Yep.

Good job to Lea and Lopen though. I think they could have gotten another mislynch or two in any other game.

Lopen Win he was:

Whiskey- scum GodFather Exicutioner

Youre my favorite type of Liquor namely Bourbon. I like to enjoy a glass of whiskey from time to time, Bullet Bourbon probably being my favorite and Monkey Shoulder for an inexpensive scotch. There are multiple types of Whiskey that most people may not realize. Rye, Bourbon, Tennessee, Irish, scotch, malt. The list goes on. The real question you must be asking yourself is what does Whiskey have to do with your role well... executioner is a good way to end the day just like a glass of Whiskey. In the movies and on TV people of power and wealth always drink Whiskey or scotch out of a fancy decanter and its always kind of cool looking.
Since you have power like those in the movies you can pay off anyone who scans you and they will think you are town.

So on a day of your choosing tell this moderator you'd like to sit back and relax by killing someone during the day phase. Since you have strength and power no one will know you stopped the day and scan clean.

https://discord.gg/7sGRYDVx

You win when Liquor becomes the primary Alcohol

Lea Wins:
Moonshine scum Brainshocker(funny version of a roleblocker)

Youre moonshine the Liquor of the back woods. Moonshine is a fun and interesting Liquor. I went on vacation to Gatlinburg Tennessee and had a VIP tour of Sugarland shine that includes a free moonshine cocktail, and a free taste testing of 12 half shots of moonshine. Moonshine is a fun beverage that can come in many flavors that are added during the distilling process. Beware though if it is not made correctly it could really hurt someone. You may ask how Brainshocker makes sense like I said moonshine can be dangerous just like you targeting them, will cause their brain to get foggy.

So each night you will choose a traget, they will now target themself and not who they intended to target.

https://discord.gg/7sGRYDVx

You win when Liquor is the primary Alcohol.

Ben Wins:
Vodka scum cop finder

Im not a huge fan of Vodka but it is the ultimate base for a mixed drink. Vodka takes the flavor of the ingredients it is mixed with pretty well. You may ask yourself what does Vodka have to do with a cop finder? Well I just answered that. It takes flavor of what it is mixed with and it takes something good to fins a taste id like.

So each night try to find the flavor you like and the role you'd like to kill or neutralize you will receive back cop or not a cop.

https://discord.gg/7sGRYDVx

You win when Liquor is the primary Alcohol

FYI....

Remaining Town: All Vanillas, save for Plum who was indeed Cop

Scum:
Lea - Brainshock roleblocker (redirects role to person using it)
Ben - Cop finder
Lopen - Godfather executioner (dayvig that ends day)

I apologize for not realizing what Sultan's intentions were for some of those roles. If I had known the full extent of what they were, I'd have told him that this inevitably could have happened. Next time I co-host I'm gonna ask for the full PMs and not just the list of roles. (We did fine-tune some things but it still ended up imbalanced by outcome - we should've known this would've been possible)

Only thing that I am going to apologize for is ending day on the Mzero Day Gambler.

Desperato is intended to be used that way and it was an oversight ending day with the executioner was dumb

Lmfao at plum. Literally took your game from hero to zero so quick.

We could have played it safe but most people weren't having fun it looked like

I think we played well and I think the setup was fairly close to balanced. Town had a LOT

I would still never include day vig that ends day in any setup though as any alignment. You need lynches in mafia. Non-result days suck the life out of the room.

Lopen posted...

We could have played it safe but most people weren't having fun it looked like

I think we played well and I think the setup was fairly close to balanced. Town had a LOT

I would still never include day vig that ends day in any setup though as any alignment. You need lynches in mafia. Non-result days suck the life out of the room.

I was complaining to Sultan from day 1 on lol.

Fun fact we killed Han with that timing as a joke and it ended up winning us the game due to confusing town (and removing the mason pair since my teammates deduced it was Han x Red when Han flipped)

Lopen posted...

Fun fact we killed Han with that timing as a joke and it ended up winning us the game due to confusing town (and removing the mason pair since my teammates deduced it was Han x Red when Han flipped)

I only voted myself because I didn't care and the game was going to be a loss anyways. No matter 3 or 4 scum, there was no way to stop it with no lynches to draw off of early on.

Dead town chat

https://discord.gg/dtSrmd2f

Mason Board
https://discord.gg/yfFZF9em

Godfather executioner (dayvig that ends day)

wow

Okay I know it was supposed to be unbalanced. But thats more what I would call "no balance at all"

Corrik7 posted...

I only voted myself because I didn't care and the game was going to be a loss anyways. No matter 3 or 4 scum, there was no way to stop it with no lynches to draw off of early on.

More Plum I'm saying was confused

I'm aware you did it due to being checked out. I do think the game was winnable but I think Lea and I played a solid game so we probably just mislynch Sheep later if the game continues.

Lol

Ok then

I mean I assumed 3 scum and 4 scum were impossible so it had to be 3+1

I'm which case corrik was the only one that could be the +1

Well there we go. I don't think the logic was wrong

Poor Marth

And corrik.... I never was actually going to not lynch Ben today. It was a gambit to see what Ben would say

The only town vote on you

Was you

Lopen posted...

More Plum I'm saying was confused

I'm aware you did it due to being checked out. I do think the game was winnable but I think Lea and I played a solid game so we probably just mislynch Sheep later if the game continues.

Winnable? Isn't the game over if Mzero just shoots me day 1 and Marth hides behind Lea?

Scum took control of the lynch. That game burns in the fires of hell. I was fighting for the game the most by trying to end it as fast as possible. I was playing for the community to not lose, screw town in that. Lol.

I agree it's good logic that's why I put it out there

That being said the setup is "balanced" I feel if you replaced the weak doc with normal doc and didn't make the day kills end day. Like it's very close

Day kills ending the day should basically never exist in mafia though. Town just deflates so hard.

masterplum posted...

And corrik.... I never was actually going to not lynch Ben today. It was a gambit to see what Ben would say

The only town vote on you

Was you

I had the best town vote today, tbqh. Like I said, let's do it now instead of 2-4 days from now. This game had a banned role.

Lopen posted...

I agree it's good logic that's why I put it out there

That being said the setup is "balanced" I feel if you replaced the weak doc with normal doc and didn't make the day kills end day. Like it's very close

Day kills ending the day should basically never exist in mafia though. Town just deflates so hard.

I agree with this

There have definitely been times Ive been loud wrong and been ashamed

This is not one of those times.

Why
Is day ended?

Sent to: TheSultanOfSlam on 12/28/2022 8:30:22 PM
This message was first read on 12/28/2022 9:29:44 PM

don't know why
We are being denied any lynches to get information and the days keep ending with extra kills and shots, but this is personally making this game very unfun for me.
Sent to: TheSultanOfSlam on 12/30/2022 8:46:59 AM
This message was first read on 12/30/2022 8:51:04 AM

I was losing it

Yeah, we all agree the setup was a bit (okay, A LOT) off, and can use it as a cautionary tale for future hosting. Not every game is going to run smoothly, and we're in the holiday funk.

I have a suggestion for a day-ending kill to have an announcement (like poisoner) with the option to have someone else intercept a delayed bullet (and can thus have fun interactions with Bulletproof or Mirror roles.) Having it anonymous was good for a cheap laugh but I agree it wasn't very healthy for the game state.

Corrik7 posted...

Why
Is day ended?

Sent to: TheSultanOfSlam on 12/28/2022 8:30:22 PM
This message was first read on 12/28/2022 9:29:44 PM

don't know why
We are being denied any lynches to get information and the days keep ending with extra kills and shots, but this is personally making this game very unfun for me.
Sent to: TheSultanOfSlam on 12/30/2022 8:46:59 AM
This message was first read on 12/30/2022 8:51:04 AM

I was losing it

Yeah, I could tell. Its why I didnt think you were scum.

This was a really dumb game

Plum didn't misplay

Corrik did but I entirely get why he did

That's why we risked hammering him. Lea said "I'm okay losing to bomb, it would change this story from scum winning with a banned role to a heroic tale of town winning anyway. 10 people happy vs 4 meh feelings from us" when I suggested maybe Corrik was bomb and that made it very clear we had to be the heroes of this story

Praise scum

Lopen posted...

Plum didn't misplay

Corrik did but I entirely get why he did

That's why we risked hammering him. Lea said "I'm okay losing to bomb, it would change this story from scum winning with a banned role to a heroic tale of town winning anyway. 10 people happy vs 4 meh feelings from us" when I suggested maybe Corrik was bomb and that made it very clear we had to be the heroes of this story

Praise scum

Wish I had been atomic bomb

Hey plum, can we work on you not dragging out sure lynches as town also?

The last time he didn't drag out things, scum me hammered Ben to death.
So I understand his hesitation.

Corrik7 posted...

Hey plum, can we work on you not dragging out sure lynches as town also?

This isn't a plum thing this is a b8 town thing lol

Days that end in well under 48 get town wins more often imo

I think the last time anyone ever voted someone else out early was me in SW/P mafia.

I guess I'm Scum Laxative.

Now that we won can I say that my self vote was strategic so that I could test and see if self voting was allowed in case it became relevant to win the game later?

Also another reason to ban self voting in future games imo

Something is obviously off when town loses at one mislynch. Like yes, game swings a lot to the other side if MZero shoots right, but most of town still had to win without mislynching a single time.

Didn't really feel like I was in this game. I had trouble being around day 1, was legit hella drunk when I was, day 2 ended before I woke up and I was hospitalized on day 3. Wasn't kidding when I said I was sick. A lot better now.

Oh, geez, I hope you're okay, ctes.

Good to hear you are improving Ctes

....

why do we have selfvotes again?

Glad you're feeling better ctes. Hopefully you fully recover quickly.

htaeD posted...

Good to hear you are improving Ctes

....

why do we have selfvotes again?

The same reason unvotes became required.

Someone did it once and then people kept doing it.

Less self votes, more pineapples, i say

Y'all pushed for pineapples for a year for explosive consequences.

Ah yikes. Glad your okay, Ctes.

I only had an ear infection, but could not focus at all.

I wish I was good at mafia & could explain myself better.. But glad I at least had Lopen and Isquen!

Holy shit I was right about Lea!

Lopen had me completely fooled, though.

Oh well. Thanks for hosting, Sultan and BCT!

(Moving to https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80299434)

Didn't need a mislynch.

10/4 mzero kills town not named Marth, scum kills

7/4 scum executioner, Marth hides behind scum, scum kill

4/4

No mislynches. Game over. No lynches actually even happen at all.

Thank you everyone. I'm mostly alright now. Had an infected rift in my throat that was placed in a very unlucky way so that it blocked breathing. Not the most fun New Years ever. It's mostly healed and I just have to eat carefully for a few more days.

I asked Sultan if he had anyone to replace when I called the doctor and was told to go the hospital. Gave him permission to state the reason so that it would not be meta'd as I would have replaced out completely irregardless of game state.

oh did this end?

Yupp