Board 8 > Dead by Daylight Mafia Topic 9: A Quiet Place

(+) Yeah! (+)

BCT make the claim list.

defending yourself to corrik, of all people, right now isn't helping anything.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

I wanted to park my vote on somebody I felt was trying to manipulate a mislynch. Which I felt was you and Red.

You didn't vote for red. You voted for me and created a Splinter vote.

So let me get this straight. 3 people voted red. And he was leading the lynch. And red was scum. And you voted wallz with red and me. But you wanted to "park your vote" on me or "red" yet avoided the scum in the lynch lead to splinter vote on someone with no votes elsewhere?

I'll admit who I changed my vote to wasn't exactly well-thought out. That's really all there was to it.

It DID spare Wallz being the lynch though, since I felt he was town. And that's something, isn't it?

Obellisk posted...

BCT make the claim list.

Also I have no idea what this is asking because I've very openly claimed from the start

BlueCrystalTear posted...

I'll admit who I changed my vote to wasn't exactly well-thought out. That's really all there was to it.

It DID spare Wallz being the lynch though, since I felt he was town. And that's something, isn't it?

Only on the surface. Since Brohans absence probably meant that scum didnt have the numbers to hammer the lynch they wanted or even enforce a tie.

I do think you and Ashe cant both be scum because you definitely would have voted Wallz with Red otherwise.

But whichever one of you is town could vote Red if a tiebreaker were to occur, and thats why the scum among you might have realized it was pointless and also self-incriminating to vote Wallz and put him and Red at 3-3.
Though that may be assigning too much fastpaced plotting to what was essentially just a couple of minutes.

Actually I may be overthinking this too much anyway
It looks straightforward in hindsight but for those who were there in the moment, it probably would be harder to even see where the votes would fall.

htaeD posted...

Only on the surface. Since Brohans absence probably meant that scum didnt have the numbers to hammer the lynch they wanted or even enforce a tie.

I do think you and Ashe cant both be scum because you definitely would have voted Wallz with Red otherwise.

But whichever one of you is town could vote Red if a tiebreaker were to occur, and thats why the scum among you might have realized it was pointless and also self-incriminating to vote Wallz and put him and Red at 3-3.
Though that may be assigning too much fastpaced plotting to what was essentially just a couple of minutes.

Wallz woulda had 4 then. He was at 3 with me red and bct on him.

Wallz 3
Red 3
Brohan 2

Then bct moves to corrik

Wallz 2
Red 3
Brohan 2
Corrik 1

If me and Red are scum together and brohan town, we could switch to brohan and there is nothing town could do to not lose at that point. It woulda been.

Brohan 4
Red 3
Corrik 1

Even with a switch from corrik to red, town can't win without brohans vote.

This is why me and Red being scum together doesn't really work.

Can we talk about how Ashe said he was blocked? I definitely didn't block him and why would scum block Ashe tonight?

BlueCrystalTear posted...

Also I have no idea what this is asking because I've very openly claimed from the start

the list of all the claims, the excel sheet that was being passed around like 10 topics ago. go find it and retype it with new info.

Corrik7 posted...

Can we talk about how Ashe said he was blocked? I definitely didn't block him and why would scum block Ashe tonight?

Let me guess, you also didnt know he claimed to basically be a cop

this is why we need that document!

If BCT wont do it, I will!

I will give you 3 town points for doing it death, but reserve the right to make additional requirements and/or exceptions upon receipt and review of same.

Though here is the last version

EDumey posted...

I spent entirely too long attempting to be budget FD.

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/forum/5/582ba29f.png

I should note that the wording makes Ulti's role sound like a psychic (like IGCD claimed), but he was actually a watcher-type motion detector (he didnt get names)

Corrik7 posted...

Can we talk about how Ashe said he was blocked? I definitely didn't block him and why would scum block Ashe tonight?

I mean who else would they have blocked? I'd assume maybe you if you were town, but I don't think you are.

Ashethan posted...

I mean who else would they have blocked? I'd assume maybe you if you were town, but I don't think you are.

If you think I'm scum then I had to of roleblocked you and I already said who I roleblocked durrrr.

Has anyone else targeted bct all game

Wallz did, night3

Takes my theory out that bct roleblocks visitors

No he cant be an untargetable

We also have confirmed visits to Corrik/BCT (Wallz) and me (Edumey)
And if we are to believe you, Ashe and BCT have also been visited.

Sbell and IGCD are unpopular, lol
But probably not untargetable anyway

Dont know why I had to say BCT twice there
I meant that you claimed to have targeted Brohan.

Though that would mean Brohan hide
Or you know, he does not have the ability to hide.
Easy to fake it when you never use it.

yeah the no use hide is hard to swallow

I am doubly unpopular. wasn't visited and wasn't forced to visit anyone.

I ctrl+f'd 'red' across 8 topics for this:

Day1
Brohan didnt like that red didnt claim flavor with his trait, but he also says red sounds like annoyed town. So ended ambivalently there. He also called Peafs discord comment about Red a reach. Thats about the only useful Brohan+Red data.

Ashe didnt react to the Red claim day1 and I asked him about this day2. He said he didnt want to meta it too hard but also could not imagine a proper flavor for a miller. Day3 Ashethan wanted Red to explain himself more when JC voted Red, but did not attack him heavily

Lea didnt mention Red day1. On day2 BCT didnt like how Edumey wanted to after the uncountered miller Red. Then on day4 BCT called Red a good target to pursue along with Brohan and Corrik. Though later he said the same about Wallz and Brohan instead (and Sultan who'd claimed 3p by then) and didnt mention Red again (day 3 or day4)

Corrik first mentioned Red day2 and was curious as to why Edumey thought Red was scum trapped in a miller claim. Day3 Corrik also asked Wallz how he could have formed an opinion on Red.

Day4 Sbell then claimed miller and the question was asked who would people rather kill, Red or Sbell? Wallz and me said Red. Corrik, Ashe and BCt were around but either didnt see or care for the question. (But to be fair neither did anyone else)
Then when the autohammer Sultan plan was proposed, Corrik was against it because: he didnt trust Sultan .

JC's vote on Red day3 also didnt gain any traction btw.

...

Basically what I get from this ISO is neutral data on Ashe and BCT, but Corrik seemed to want to play soft defense for Red more than once. This is not scummy by itself, but it does add up nicely to his already scummy image.

No soft defense anywhere you are grasping and clearly only grasping to one party over and over again.

I am assuming3 scum remaining so yeah my parties are not gonna look too varied

htaeD posted...

I am assuming3 scum remaining so yeah my parties are not gonna look too varied

Well I guarantee any parties with me in it are wrong.

Corrik7 posted...

Well I guarantee any parties with me in it are wrong.

red said the same...

...to be fair

Whatever

##vote: Brohan

Brohan red and bct scum.

Indy in one of you left. Probably death since he fence sat all game. Final answer.

are we no longer in a mylo / lylo & stitch situation?

We are comfortable dropping a vote with 29 hours till days end?

Well if its between you and Brohan I would vote Brohan first since I literally cannot picture a scumteam without him on it.
Though you are probably both scum anyway.

Either way I am going to sleep early, so I am well rested for tomorrow.
Dont do anything crazy without me.

Obellisk posted...

are we no longer in a mylo / lylo & stitch situation?

We are comfortable dropping a vote with 29 hours till days end?

Its not Mylo Corrik says.
I say Corrik doesnt want us to know its Mylo.

htaeD posted...

Its not Mylo Corrik says.
I say Corrik doesnt want us to know its Mylo.

how has it changed? if there are 3 scum and 7 alive... how is that different from 4 and 9?

It hasnt
Corriks theory is that it wasnt Mylo yesterday either.

Not impossible
But also not helpful to base scumhunts on that possibility.

The only thing that changed is that we saw that scum could not get Wallz lynched and did not want to lynch Brohan.

Corrik is the lynch today, then I'd have to guess brohan, then it gets a little trickier

Does a town Corrik try to go to all these lengths to prove himself town? I don't think so. He's trying to create a narrative that we're supposed to eat up and I'm not having any of it.

I'm town who keeps changing his mind as new info comes out. I don't get why anyone would think I'm scum after how many people say that I'm not going to be ballsy enough to claim town ninja and roleblocker as scum. And they're right.

the more he says he's town the more I doubt it.

it bothers me bct. just say it less.

Either way the only people that should be getting votes today are Corrik and Brohan.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Either way the only people that should be getting votes today are Corrik and Brohan.

I'll remember this for later in case once of them is town and we only have three scum.

But I'm pretty convinced that Corrik is scum. Brohan still needs to post more. And I'm still bugged by Ethan saying he was a killer first now that we know for sure that scum is killers when town is survivors and vice-versa.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

I'll remember this for later in case once of them is town and we only have three scum.

What?

IfGodCouldDie posted...

What?

Because it's best to not cross off any suspects and question motivation for everything in a game like this.

That and we needed more content since scum isn't talking. I was hoping to give them something to pounce on.

The irony of the topic title isn't last on me. Was its apt descriptor a curse?

Lost, not last

Damn Auto-erect

(Isquen, is it okay to edit minor typos?)

Well IfGodCouldDie posted...

Either way the only people that should be getting votes today are Corrik and Brohan.

Agreed.
But since I still cant be around for deadline, we should at least decide who beforeI leave
I dont want the votes to be split and all

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Either way the only people that should be getting votes today are Corrik and Brohan.

If you believe it is mylo then duh. That's what I said yesterday regarding death and brohan and people went all over the place. That's why we were lucky it apparently wasn't mylo or scum couldn't get their votes online.