Advokaiser posted... Wow, you were nearly identical to my case!
* Divisions 2 and 6 being the only ones perfect.
* Picking Ultimate > Odyssey, and RE2 > Bloodborne correctly; though I actually had DQXI > Sekiro
* My biggest blunders being TLOU > Dark Souls, and Skyrim > Witcher (if I had picked the latter right, I would've finished 2nd overall; both picks right would've granted me the site-wide victory)
* Took me a while to sneak myself into the leaderboard.
* I had P4G winning to RDR but losing to GTAV, hence having GTAV in the spanision finals; but I also had a really hard time picking between Xenoblade and Three Houses; ultimately went with Xenoblade winning its spanision without any solid reason to and it payed off extremely well.
I think the ghosts of 2015 messed me up a bit. I overestimated Undertale and underestimated ME3 (thinking Starcraft would beat it, lol, but that was also definitely my strategy PC gamer bias even if I don't play it myself), thought Uncharted would do better than it did, and didn't really account for Witcher's strength coming onto the scene in relation to Skyrim. Bear in mind I have played none of the games I have mentioned in this posts, though I'd be open to most all of them. I also underestimated Dark Souls due to my own bias with it not being the kind of game I play at all (yet somehow overestimated TLOU despite also being a game I will never play, but I've heard lots of praise about here, so maybe it's neither here nor there).
---
"The truth is rarely pure and never simple."