Board 8 > Mercenaries 4 Mafia Topic 3: Yuffie steals gravy's Create Mafia Topic ability.

(+) Yeah! (+)

May be a while until she gives it back.

1. Ben
2. VI
3. Ulti
4. IfGodCouldDie
5. JohnBobb
6. Death (replaced JC)
7. Kanz
8. Oddity
9. Tony
10. Eaed
11. Corrik
12. Scare
13. Jaded_Eye
14. Mzero
15. Chris
16. Shad
17. Lopen
18. Leo

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch. Deadline is today at 11pm.
---

htaeD posted...

but since I am apparently talking to myself now

how come players still put stock in Corriks copclaim like it means something?
Eaed said it, and I dont think he was the only one

I am not even sure what it means, even scum would (or should) find it difficult to believe a towncorrik who claims anything

---

benjamin3740 posted...

I like Kanz and the recent posts he made. The way Corrik's posts about Ulti changed Kanz' perspective a bit and made him want to dive deeper into Ulti is also a town tell to be. He seems genuine

---

Claiming Cop as Cop for me is safe. No one will believe it and lets me get my scans off.
---

htaeD posted...

htaeD posted...

but since I am apparently talking to myself now

how come players still put stock in Corriks copclaim like it means something?
Eaed said it, and I dont think he was the only one

I am not even sure what it means, even scum would (or should) find it difficult to believe a towncorrik who claims anything

Yeah Oddity believed Corrik for some reason. But I've never played with oddity and don't know hours experience playing with Corrik.

Corrik says he doesn't always claim cop day 1. He "claims scans" . Claiming scans IS claiming cop -.-
---

Yeah eaedwards's posts from last night felt extremely weak, even by eaedwards standards

What do you think of me, death of htaeD?
---

Tag
---

I suppose Corrik and Ben are here and make a good enough audience

PJBasis, TOWN Vanilla

flavor basically says PJ wasnt very memorable in Mercs 4

when Ben claimed PJ, I even considered flavorclaiming then and there. but since he was joking, (obviously to me), no counter was needed
and if I flavorclaimed, my role would be obviously not something major
I foolishly thought maybe I could get away with looking like townpower on day1 and draw a NK, and that failed quickly

and later when I started questioning Bens knowledge, it was not me thinking he drew PJbasis from a safelist
and more wondering whether someone else told him about PJ being a player in Mercs4 for some reason
I already admitted my line of thought here was rather useless
---

benjamin3740 posted...

htaeD posted...

htaeD posted...

but since I am apparently talking to myself now

how come players still put stock in Corriks copclaim like it means something?
Eaed said it, and I dont think he was the only one

I am not even sure what it means, even scum would (or should) find it difficult to believe a towncorrik who claims anything

Yeah Oddity believed Corrik for some reason. But I've never played with oddity and don't know hours experience playing with Corrik.

Corrik says he doesn't always claim cop day 1. He "claims scans" . Claiming scans IS claiming cop -.-

Oh him?
Oddity I dont mind then
he doesnt have a lot of Corrik experience I think
---

VeryInsane posted...

Yeah eaedwards's posts from last night felt extremely weak, even by eaedwards standards

What do you think of me, death of htaeD?

I like you, but it helps that I remember you not being a very heavyweight player as town in past games

again, havent had the chance to catch up last night yet tho
---

also developing a minor doubt for Eaed because he said he was busy with work a lot
its just that he seems to post useless stuff rather than trying to catch up as he promised
---

Ooooh. Interesting.

You really think I'd claim a flavor not on my safelist though?
---

htaeD posted...

I suppose Corrik and Ben are here and make a good enough audience

PJBasis, TOWN Vanilla

flavor basically says PJ wasnt very memorable in Mercs 4

when Ben claimed PJ, I even considered flavorclaiming then and there. but since he was joking, (obviously to me), no counter was needed
and if I flavorclaimed, my role would be obviously not something major
I foolishly thought maybe I could get away with looking like townpower on day1 and draw a NK, and that failed quickly

and later when I started questioning Bens knowledge, it was not me thinking he drew PJbasis from a safelist
and more wondering whether someone else told him about PJ being a player in Mercs4 for some reason
I already admitted my line of thought here was rather useless

An interesting claim. I also think it suggests Ben as Town, surprisingly. I dunno if I buy it but hey at least you've been consistent right now

##unvote:
---

htaeD posted...

I suppose Corrik and Ben are here and make a good enough audience

PJBasis, TOWN Vanilla

flavor basically says PJ wasnt very memorable in Mercs 4

when Ben claimed PJ, I even considered flavorclaiming then and there. but since he was joking, (obviously to me), no counter was needed
and if I flavorclaimed, my role would be obviously not something major
I foolishly thought maybe I could get away with looking like townpower on day1 and draw a NK, and that failed quickly

and later when I started questioning Bens knowledge, it was not me thinking he drew PJbasis from a safelist
and more wondering whether someone else told him about PJ being a player in Mercs4 for some reason
I already admitted my line of thought here was rather useless

Vanilla claim is what I expected from a replace tbqh
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Ooooh. Interesting.

You really think I'd claim a flavor not on my safelist though?

at the time it did cross my mind, if you could pass it off as a joke, there wouldnt be any harm to backpedaling
but I dont think much of it now, as I said 'useless line of thought'
---

Can someone post votals?
---

And I assume all your current suspicion of me then is how I talked about Leo as if I'd played more than 3 games with him?
---

htaeD posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Ooooh. Interesting.

You really think I'd claim a flavor not on my safelist though?

at the time it did cross my mind, if you could pass it off as a joke, there wouldnt be any harm to backpedaling
but I dont think much of it now, as I said 'useless line of thought'

Alright, fair enough.

##Unvote
---

there was something else buried in between UltiVSCorrik, let me refresh my memory
(sidenote: I also wonder if it means something that both of them have unequivocally called me town)

oh right, how could I forget
it was you going after me for being a replacement for so long, which struck me as lazy
now you gave other reasons okay
so I will ask
have you seen scum replace out before a game ever started?
---

I can comment but you'll get mad at me so nah
---

I'm not a co-host so I don't know if Leo is actually a double voter votals

[5] Ben - (Ulti), Scare, MZero, Leo1, Leo2, death
[3] Ulti - (IGCD), Corrik, Lopen, Ulti
[2] Corrik - Shad, (VI), Ulti
[2] MZero - (Oddity), Kanz, Oddity
[1] Death - (Chris), Chris, (VI)
[1] Johnbobb - (Kanz), Tony
[0] Oddity - (Lopen)
[0] Kanz - (MZero)
[0] Chris - (Corrik)
[0] Leo - (VI), (Ben), (Death), (Oddity), (Chris)
[0] Lopen - (IGCD), (Oddity), (Ulti), (Chris)
[0] IGCD - (Ulti), (Oddity)
[0] VI - (Ulti), (Ulti), (Oddity), (Oddity)
---

So am I the only one who sees everything Death has said about Ben this page and is burning a hole into his vote on him?
---

htaeD posted...

there was something else buried in between UltiVSCorrik, let me refresh my memory
(sidenote: I also wonder if it means something that both of them have unequivocally called me town)

oh right, how could I forget
it was you going after me for being a replacement for so long, which struck me as lazy
now you gave other reasons okay
so I will ask
have you seen scum replace out before a game ever started?

Yes definitely. Quite a few times. And I watched most of CT mafia if you want the most recent example
---

Hm

I actually think I like everybody with multiple votes (even MZero)
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

So am I the only one who sees everything Death has said about Ben this page and is burning a hole into his vote on him?

I am not quite familiar with the expression, but it doesnt sound like it fits my mindset
what are you saying here?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

htaeD posted...

there was something else buried in between UltiVSCorrik, let me refresh my memory
(sidenote: I also wonder if it means something that both of them have unequivocally called me town)

oh right, how could I forget
it was you going after me for being a replacement for so long, which struck me as lazy
now you gave other reasons okay
so I will ask
have you seen scum replace out before a game ever started?

Yes definitely. Quite a few times. And I watched most of CT mafia if you want the most recent example

oh it happened there too?
didnt even realize
---

You are voting for someone who fake claimed something that you 100% know was not on a safelist. You think this is a scum action. What???
---

htaeD posted...

also developing a minor doubt for Eaed because he said he was busy with work a lot
its just that he seems to post useless stuff rather than trying to catch up as he promised

In Chrono Trigger, I got to do most of my playing at work. So when game started on Monday night I figured I would catch up Tuesday at work but I was slammed yesterday. No so much today. I want to catch up but it is gonna be hard to do. This game has been very active despite what Ulti was saying halfway through topic 2 and there is a lot of content there. I have read half of topic 1 and half of topic 2. I feel like Corrik and Ulti were putting on a show last night. I am feeling even worse on Corrik because despite what I said in one of my first posts yesterday Corrik has been much more active today than he was last game and he was town last game.
---

When did Ben state he was joking?

Couldn't find it on the first page of Topic 1
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

You are voting for someone who fake claimed something that you 100% know was not on a safelist. You think this is a scum action. What???

several things
1. I am not voting him at all, I already said he's only on the edge of my suspectlist
2. I am not suspecting him for claiming what wasnt on a safelist. I did not say that it was a scum action

the fact that he did claim something not from a safelist as a joke is not 100 % assurance that he is town to me.
Its not even that risky If you ask me
I would call him town normally still, but some aspects of him nagged at me, so I brought those up
---

wait..
what?
my is my name on the Benjamin votelist?
I am pretty sure I didnt ever vote him
---

VeryInsane posted...

When did Ben state he was joking?

Couldn't find it on the first page of Topic 1

he stated it later
I just assumed it was a joke right away primarily because hey I was PJ already and no way scum (or town) would 'seriously' risk fakeclaiming PJ
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

htaeD posted...

also developing a minor doubt for Eaed because he said he was busy with work a lot
its just that he seems to post useless stuff rather than trying to catch up as he promised

In Chrono Trigger, I got to do most of my playing at work. So when game started on Monday night I figured I would catch up Tuesday at work but I was slammed yesterday. No so much today. I want to catch up but it is gonna be hard to do. This game has been very active despite what Ulti was saying halfway through topic 2 and there is a lot of content there. I have read half of topic 1 and half of topic 2. I feel like Corrik and Ulti were putting on a show last night. I am feeling even worse on Corrik because despite what I said in one of my first posts yesterday Corrik has been much more active today than he was last game and he was town last game.

so you feel more swamped here than in CT?
---

Ben voted for Death and I wrote it as Death voting for Ben votal corrections

[4] Ben - (Ulti), Scare, MZero, Leo1, Leo2
[3] Ulti - (IGCD), Corrik, Lopen, IGCD
[2] Corrik - Shad, (VI), Ulti
[2] MZero - (Oddity), Kanz, Oddity
[2] Death - (Chris), Ben, Chris, (VI)
[1] Johnbobb - (Kanz), Tony
[0] Oddity - (Lopen)
[0] Kanz - (MZero)
[0] Chris - (Corrik)
[0] Leo - (VI), (Ben), (Death), (Oddity), (Chris)
[0] Lopen - (IGCD), (Oddity), (Ulti), (Chris)
[0] IGCD - (Ulti), (Oddity)
[0] VI - (Ulti), (Ulti), (Oddity), (Oddity)
---

good
I havent gone senile then
---

htaeD posted...

there was something else buried in between UltiVSCorrik, let me refresh my memory
(sidenote: I also wonder if it means something that both of them have unequivocally called me town)

oh right, how could I forget
it was you going after me for being a replacement for so long, which struck me as lazy
now you gave other reasons okay
so I will ask
have you seen scum replace out before a game ever started?

I never called you town.
---

Pretty sure Ulti is not voting for Ulti

Anyway yeah I looked at it and I am unsure about the lack of reaction there. Like I don't think you even responded to the Miller claim (even if it was a joke)
---

Corrik posted...

htaeD posted...

there was something else buried in between UltiVSCorrik, let me refresh my memory
(sidenote: I also wonder if it means something that both of them have unequivocally called me town)

oh right, how could I forget
it was you going after me for being a replacement for so long, which struck me as lazy
now you gave other reasons okay
so I will ask
have you seen scum replace out before a game ever started?

I never called you town.

could have sworn
dear me if I confused Ulti for you
---

Oh okay, that's a lot less bad then <_<. You can see my problem with that.

##unvote: Death

Hm, interesting and more interesting.
---

htaeD posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

htaeD posted...

also developing a minor doubt for Eaed because he said he was busy with work a lot
its just that he seems to post useless stuff rather than trying to catch up as he promised

In Chrono Trigger, I got to do most of my playing at work. So when game started on Monday night I figured I would catch up Tuesday at work but I was slammed yesterday. No so much today. I want to catch up but it is gonna be hard to do. This game has been very active despite what Ulti was saying halfway through topic 2 and there is a lot of content there. I have read half of topic 1 and half of topic 2. I feel like Corrik and Ulti were putting on a show last night. I am feeling even worse on Corrik because despite what I said in one of my first posts yesterday Corrik has been much more active today than he was last game and he was town last game.

so you feel more swamped here than in CT?

Just at the moment because my son is sick at home so I had even less time than usual. That being said the deadline for my project at work was yesterday so I should be good to get back to work here in mafia.
---

Is MI official as CoHost?
---

Hey Eaed so how are you feeling about me now? I know you had vague notions of displeasure before.
---

VeryInsane posted...

Pretty sure Ulti is not voting for Ulti

Anyway yeah I looked at it and I am unsure about the lack of reaction there. Like I don't think you even responded to the Miller claim (even if it was a joke)

I figured even outright saying 'haha very funny Ben' would give too much info away for what was just a joke
especially now that it seems not everyone took it as a joke right away

thats why I asked

knowing nothing of Mercenaries
could a flavor claim even tell that much about roles?

because I was considering countering Ben briefly
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Oh okay, that's a lot less bad then <_<. You can see my problem with that.

its okay, I forgive you
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Hey Eaed so how are you feeling about me now? I know you had vague notions of displeasure before.

Chris, I would be lying if I said I have ever had a good read on you. That being said despite what I said earlier I am leaning town because the Lopen I would credit more to it being day 1 than you being scum looking for a weak case on someone.
---

while the subject is me
Mzero did seem to be genuinely trying to scumhunt when he raised some points about me
---

Death, you mentioned Corrik's cop claim. How do you feel about it? Do you feel it is real or just Corrik being Corrik?
---

also I am reminded of another thing that still bugs me, despite everything, about you Ben
the 'I will scan as town'
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Death, you mentioned Corrik's cop claim. How do you feel about it? Do you feel it is real or just Corrik being Corrik?

I took it as Corrik being Corrik
its as real as schrodingers cat's livelihood
---

htaeD posted...

also I am reminded of another thing that still bugs me, despite everything, about you Ben
the 'I will scan as town'

Wouldn't town just say something along the lines of I'm town. Not scan as town?
---