Board 8 > Valentine's Day Mafia Topic 9: And I Will Always Love You

(+) Yeah! (+)

Corrik7 posted...

And what data is that

Kirby's suspicions. You can see how they have progressed as the game has gone on. They're irrational.

He is directly saying that if he flips town I will suddenly start playing rationally and solve

Even though I'm his number one scum read

Thank goodness JC saved me. Your ability to think you understand the game after reading 5% of it is unreal

Kirby did also pair up with Chris to get prosty-scanned and then broke up with him because 'gf prosty is untenable'

still don't get that one

Yeah. My death will probably also provide fire against Isquen, since he was so confidently arrogant about his reads earlier. He was unfortunately wrong about me, but at least he shouldn't get an easy ride to EoD after my flip.

The problem is we've still got a wide PoE.
Corrik is going to die.
Chris is going to confirm that FD doesn't move, but that means nothing with FD knowing he's being slept with.
Lopen/Ulti/Kirby still unresolved.
MZero and Isquen will be under suspicion.
Sultan still suspicious.

My advice for town is to have Lopen ignore Kirby tomorrow, take a shot in MZero/Isquen/Sultan. I think Lopen's insistence on trying to "Resolve" D1 was a huge red herring this game that made it harder to solve.

Corrik7 posted...

You wanna kill someone so lopen will shut up but he will just not shut up about someone else then.

I already says if Kirby flips town I'll take a vow of silence

You want me to stop messing the game up and think they're both town? Do it

Lopen posted...

Kirby's suspicions. You can see how they have progressed as the game has gone on. They're irrational.

He is directly saying that if he flips town I will suddenly start playing rationally and solve

Even though I'm his number one scum read

Thank goodness JC saved me. Your ability to think you understand the game after reading 5% of it is unreal

11.6% thank you.

Chaeix posted...

Kirby did also pair up with Chris to get prosty-scanned and then broke up with him because 'gf prosty is untenable'

still don't get that one

Prosty is pointless with two scum left.

Corrik

Lynch Kirby and I'll shut up even if he's scum how about that to sweeten the pot

Lopen posted...

Corrik

Lynch Kirby and I'll shut up even if he's scum how about that to sweeten the pot

This means nothing to me.

If this game doesn't have a person to force a date to effectively be mayor then this game missed big time.

Corrik7 posted...

You wanna kill someone so lopen will shut up but he will just not shut up about someone else then.

You seem to think this hurts the game

You have the power to shut me up forever by dating Dumey

Corrik7 posted...

Edumey, do you think Kirby is scum? If so, why?

Kirby do you think edumey is scum? If so why?

My opinion hasn't changed that much from before. I think Kirby is probably like 95% town. But admittedly, Kirby has TWO end of day scenario's pointing against him.

D1. I know I'm town and Peaf left my date to hang himself up. Could have been a solo play by Peaf, or an attempt to save Kirby.
D2. I know I'm town and Ulti gave his life to me, and urged me to dump him to save Red, before Kirby took the Red date. There was a chance Kirby gets killed there. I talked about this with Lopen earlier, and I think there is a universe where exactly Ulti + Kirby explains motivation here. Otherwise Ulti is town.

So basically I think scum is exactly Ulti + Kirby, or both are probably town.

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80712690

EDumey posted...

My opinion hasn't changed that much from before. I think Kirby is probably like 95% town. But admittedly, Kirby has TWO end of day scenario's pointing against him.

D1. I know I'm town and Peaf left my date to hang himself up. Could have been a solo play by Peaf, or an attempt to save Kirby.
D2. I know I'm town and Ulti gave his life to me, and urged me to dump him to save Red, before Kirby took the Red date. There was a chance Kirby gets killed there. I talked about this with Lopen earlier, and I think there is a universe where exactly Ulti + Kirby explains motivation here. Otherwise Ulti is town.

So basically I think scum is exactly Ulti + Kirby, or both are probably town.

Is there any scenario where a town Kirby wouldn't do exactly the same?