Lurker > masterplum

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, Database 4 ( 07.23.2018-12.31.2018 ), DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear
Board List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 17
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:56:44 PM
#120
DYL is more likely scum but Im not lynching an unclaimed who hasnt posted in a day. What a terrible move
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:54:59 PM
#108
Corrik posted...
masterplum posted...
Corrik posted...
Plum, claim or die. Last chance. You have 6 minutes.


No

Bye, Felicia.


Suck it
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:54:04 PM
#101
Corrik posted...
Plum, claim or die. Last chance. You have 6 minutes.


No
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:53:56 PM
#98
benjamin3740 posted...
masterplum posted...
benjamin3740 posted...
Sheep007 posted...
masterplum posted...
So shad obviously is implying he has a scan on me at this point.

There are two options here.

1. Shad is scum who is trying to imply a scan to try to save himself
2. Shad is town and is either leaping to conclusions or got bussed or something.

I dont think 1 makes very much sense here. He is playing it too hard.

But then again he isnt playing it hard enough if he thinks he actuslly has a scan. It feels like the Mike Birbiglia skit. Im right here bear, come and get me

##unvote

Might just have to wait for his next move

This is the post that people think is one of the most individually damning iirc. Plum basically saying he thinks Shad has a scan on him (without too much to make him think that way, imo). This is classic scum paranoia, and obviously the assumption someone is trying to claim a guilty scan on you isn't really the first line of thinking for town in most situations where it isn't blatant (which this wouldn't be).

Come on Plum. Explain this.


It wasnt. This was after he pressed me like a thousand times and claimed phantom theif

So did you assume he had the thief role or the cop role?


None of these. I didnt assume anything. None of these would find me guilty. I postulated if such a possibility existed
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:52:48 PM
#89
ScareChan posted...
Remember when plum called me town and han scum

And then ducked hans dick and voted reg


Remember when I didnt suck at this game and change opinions?
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:52:18 PM
#87
benjamin3740 posted...
Sheep007 posted...
masterplum posted...
So shad obviously is implying he has a scan on me at this point.

There are two options here.

1. Shad is scum who is trying to imply a scan to try to save himself
2. Shad is town and is either leaping to conclusions or got bussed or something.

I dont think 1 makes very much sense here. He is playing it too hard.

But then again he isnt playing it hard enough if he thinks he actuslly has a scan. It feels like the Mike Birbiglia skit. Im right here bear, come and get me

##unvote

Might just have to wait for his next move

This is the post that people think is one of the most individually damning iirc. Plum basically saying he thinks Shad has a scan on him (without too much to make him think that way, imo). This is classic scum paranoia, and obviously the assumption someone is trying to claim a guilty scan on you isn't really the first line of thinking for town in most situations where it isn't blatant (which this wouldn't be).

Come on Plum. Explain this.


It wasnt. This was after he pressed me like a thousand times and claimed phantom theif
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:51:15 PM
#80
Sheep007 posted...
I feel more confident with a DYL lynch so will be staying there for now but if I have to pick from anyone else I'm glad it's Plum.


##unvote
##vote:sheep


The most convenient opinion ever
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:50:22 PM
#75
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:47:47 PM
#62
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:47:11 PM
#60
ScareChan posted...
masterplum posted...
benjamin3740 posted...
ScareChan posted...
masterplum posted...
Of course scare votes me. He is trash at this game


You were literally PART OF THE REASON that there is precedent from previous games that makes me confirmed

Get your bullshit out of here

Yeah Plum you said I had to be modkilled because it would make me look "confirmed town" if I wasnt, and it would be cheating


I literally never said this


...what?

Are you seriously trying to pull this


Thought I was replying to you
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:46:44 PM
#56
There is no reason scares action was unintentional and he is scum. Easily could be a miscommunication on the scum board. It means nothing
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:45:50 PM
#53
benjamin3740 posted...
ScareChan posted...
masterplum posted...
Of course scare votes me. He is trash at this game


You were literally PART OF THE REASON that there is precedent from previous games that makes me confirmed

Get your bullshit out of here

Yeah Plum you said I had to be modkilled because it would make me look "confirmed town" if I wasnt, and it would be cheating


I literally never said this
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:44:14 PM
#47
ScareChan posted...
masterplum posted...
Of course scare votes me. He is trash at this game


You were literally PART OF THE REASON that there is precedent from previous games that makes me confirmed

Get your bullshit out of here


YOU DIDNT ACT IN A WAY THAT MAKES YOU LOOK GOOD

ITS NOT THE SAME
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:43:29 PM
#44
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:41:09 PM
#35
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:35:53 PM
#21
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:35:30 PM
#19
Sheep007 posted...
masterplum posted...
Ok, back for a bit. Whats the case on DYL? He just hasnt been around?

Also did a bad vote on Ed, suspected me vocally then followed me onto Ed anyway, had a few crappy sounding posts, and everyone else just generally looks a lot better to me. He has absolutely nothing at all that looks good (which is often my measure for finding scum).

Scare was apparently confirmed because he voted after Anonymous in the tiebreaker and wasn't modkilled iirc


Why would this confirm Scare? He voted the same way as the anonymous vote.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:34:20 PM
#16
Johnbobb posted...
htaeD posted...
What if DYL is one of the two who needs to be replaced???

htaeD posted...
I dont think DYL or Garetha are gonna give a yes or no

ugh

so we'd literally be lynching someone looking for a replacement?

:/


It was announced we are looking for 2 replacements?
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:33:39 PM
#15
Having trouble navigating on phone. Is there an actual case on DYL
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:32:22 PM
#12
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus
masterplum
12/21/18 7:31:12 PM
#8
Ok, back for a bit. Whats the case on DYL? He just hasnt been around?
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 10:50:08 AM
#285
Going to be gone almost all day. I flew to Utah to see my family. Of the people on Ed I don't want to Lynch God or Shad. I'm unsure on sheep.

Sheep might be the best option here then... Could scum not be on Ed? That seems super unlikely.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:45:09 AM
#257
Shaduln posted...
masterplum posted...
Sheep007 posted...
Corrik posted...
Would anyone like to claim yet? Preferably Sheep.

Why preferably me, Corrik? That's a hard no for now but ask again if we're both alive tomorrow.


So this is a weird post from both directions.

Sheep makes one unremarkable post, then Corrik asks sheep to claim, then sheep says he could claim under no pressure day 2?

But sheep just claimed vanilla...Why?

This feels scum/scum

Also this is plum trying to line up another lynch, assuming sheep gets lynched. Either that means he knows sheep is scum and wants to get ahead of a Corrik mislynch, or knows they're both town and wants to go "oh I guess it was only one scum".

Either way, looks good for Corrik being town.

I have literally never lined up lynches as scum in my life
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:44:30 AM
#256
DoomTheGyarados posted...
No nuanced on me "being town", eh Plum?

masterplum posted...
Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

Corrik makes good posts then does stupid things like calling Chris town. Corrik has no f***ing idea if Chris is town. Nobody does. He is Chris and has played 24 hours.

I'm not sure if that makes him more or less likely to be scum


eeSW92LLHu0qk


Im talking about why I said nuanced, not that you arent nuanced >_>
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:32:16 AM
#247
DoomTheGyarados posted...
masterplum posted...
DoomTheGyarados posted...
masterplum posted...
god, can you not get yourself killed here for no reason


Worry about yourself. Why don't I get day 1 chris status from you? This is day one from me. Where is the sheeping at


We have scum flipped which gives me more to go on. I trust you day 1 blind but once people flip it gets more nuanced

My slot voted the scum. Why is it nuanced?


Not nuanced on you being town, nuanced in a Im actuslly relatively competent after day 1 sort of way
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:28:20 AM
#243
DoomTheGyarados posted...
masterplum posted...
god, can you not get yourself killed here for no reason


Worry about yourself. Why don't I get day 1 chris status from you? This is day one from me. Where is the sheeping at


We have scum flipped which gives me more to go on. I trust you day 1 blind but once people flip it gets more nuanced
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:26:01 AM
#236
Thats super cryptic, but I think it is in best interest to not elaborate.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:25:19 AM
#234
htaeD posted...
That said Shaduln is probably town anyway.


Actually....

Oh crap. Shad is town. 100%
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:22:49 AM
#231
htaeD posted...
Shad said his status as phantom thief was obvious. ButI didnt notice any breadcrumbs or slips that made it obvious.
Chris was the one who started the thief talk as far as I recall.


Exactly.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:21:30 AM
#228
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:18:07 AM
#222
benjamin3740 posted...
/@ScareChan

Was Plum the one on our scum team who was really paranoid that you had gotten scanned by someone who was pushing you? Because him addressing Shad over being scanned. ...I really don't like. Why ever assume that if you're town?


Because he claimed he was a phantom theif obviously
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:14:02 AM
#214
So in order to clear it up, lets make another not clear post. Gee plum you sure are great at this game.

At the time I hated the post because it felt totally half hearted. Because of it I looked back at sheep and other than being a staunch reg defender not much else really stood out.

So Im conflicted
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:12:21 AM
#210
htaeD posted...
Oh
A lot of ninjaing going on here.
Plum, your explanation doesnt even make much sense, considering sheep posted more after that.

Also sheep is european, so he wasnt hiding.. at least not all the time.


Yea. I was explaining my post. Im conflicted on sheep now.

That was obviously not clear at all
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 9:03:20 AM
#199
benjamin3740 posted...
masterplum posted...
Sheep007 posted...
Hbthebattle posted...
I honestly doubt Sheep is going to show up again.

Dude... Don't go accusing me of throwing, please.

I'm Mr Ushimaru, Vanilla.


Oh.

Well hold on that vote might have been premature. This post is awful. Im going to iso sheep and see what we got

Why was that post awful?


Because there is nothing else. He claimed and left. It felt totally half hearted, exactly the post that scum sheep would make if he thought he was dead but felt bad if he rolled over and died
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 7:30:13 AM
#178
after that he is pretty consistently against a Reg lynch.

I dont know. His worst post was probably the opener and then he mellowed down.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 7:16:48 AM
#177
Sheep007 posted...
Corrik posted...
Would anyone like to claim yet? Preferably Sheep.

Why preferably me, Corrik? That's a hard no for now but ask again if we're both alive tomorrow.


So this is a weird post from both directions.

Sheep makes one unremarkable post, then Corrik asks sheep to claim, then sheep says he could claim under no pressure day 2?

But sheep just claimed vanilla...Why?

This feels scum/scum
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 6:44:54 AM
#176
Sheep007 posted...
Hbthebattle posted...
I honestly doubt Sheep is going to show up again.

Dude... Don't go accusing me of throwing, please.

I'm Mr Ushimaru, Vanilla.


Oh.

Well hold on that vote might have been premature. This post is awful. Im going to iso sheep and see what we got
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 6:43:36 AM
#175
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/21/18 12:59:56 AM
#160
So shad obviously is implying he has a scan on me at this point.

There are two options here.

1. Shad is scum who is trying to imply a scan to try to save himself
2. Shad is town and is either leaping to conclusions or got bussed or something.

I dont think 1 makes very much sense here. He is playing it too hard.

But then again he isnt playing it hard enough if he thinks he actuslly has a scan. It feels like the Mike Birbiglia skit. Im right here bear, come and get me

##unvote

Might just have to wait for his next move
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 11:14:12 PM
#147
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 10:18:46 PM
#139
Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

Corrik makes good posts then does stupid things like calling Chris town. Corrik has no f***ing idea if Chris is town. Nobody does. He is Chris and has played 24 hours.

I'm not sure if that makes him more or less likely to be scum
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 4:55:40 PM
#96
At what point do we Lynch Gareth because if he was town he would be replaced
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 3:22:03 PM
#82
DoomTheGyarados posted...
masterplum posted...
Completely agree on sk over double vig. P5 doesn't strike me as a double vig flavor

What were the vig character claims?


What. Every main character has a gun like weapon that if you hit a weak point you can fire again. Plum I am trying to show mercy but this is just wrong.

Ben, flavor?


Oh

Right. I forgot that
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 3:14:15 PM
#68
Completely agree on sk over double vig. P5 doesn't strike me as a double vig flavor

What were the vig character claims?
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 12:45:44 PM
#40
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 12:28:49 PM
#37
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut
masterplum
12/20/18 12:26:33 PM
#34
Putting these here so I can stop looking back

Arti posted...
Final Day 1 Votals
eaed [8] - (Han), Neablis, (IGCD), (ben), (Scare), (Hb), (Sheep), DYL, (Reg), Death, Reg, Sheep, Shad, IGCD, Anonymous
Reg [7] - (IGCD), Han, plum, Terra, Ashe, ben, Hb, Scare
Hb [2] - (Scare), (Reg), eaed, Johnbobb
IGCD [1] - red, (Reg), (ben), (DYL)
Johnbobb [1] - MZero
Sheep [1] - Corrik
Ben [0] - (Reg)
Corrik [0] - (plum), (Scare)
Death [0] - (plum)
MZero [0] - (Scare), (Reg)
Neablis [0] - (Reg), (Scare)
Scare [0] - (Corrik), (eaed)
Terra [0] - (Reg), (Sheep)

---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 3 - The Museum of Vanity
masterplum
12/20/18 8:05:43 AM
#448
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 3 - The Museum of Vanity
masterplum
12/20/18 7:34:33 AM
#442
Oh Im stupid. It makes sense now.

Shad was one of the last votes on the Ed train. I should have looked at the votals again before posting.

Shads plan here is that he knows the people on the Ed train are going to be scrutinized and he is one of the main targets. He also knew that people think I am scummy because people always think im scummy and decided to preemptively attack me to see if he could get a following going to protect himself.

Clever

##Vote:Shad
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 3 - The Museum of Vanity
masterplum
12/20/18 7:26:40 AM
#438
I dont get shads vote on me. He knows a lynch on me isnt going anywhere today and his reasoning is totally ridiculous. Even if I was scum why would I lie about not checking the board or thinking Corrik was being zany for the sake of being zany?

Shad is a better player than this
---
Board List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 17