Strokes are my favorite band, I would agree with your rankings too: First Impressions > This Is It > Room on Fire. I like First Impressions because it has so many of my favorite songs, even if there are some lame one later. This Is It is pretty much perfect throughout, but I like some tracks in First Impressions so much. But I think in my top 5 of their songs, there's songs from every album, so it doesn't really matter.
They're new album is distinctly bad, except for like 1 or 2 tracks (you'll know it when you hear them).
--
_foolmo_
'You are obviously intelligent and insightful' - Sir Chris about me