No, of course he doesn't. Does Ronaldo win the CL with West Brom (ignoring the fact that they weren't in it)? No, of course he doesn't.
But Argentina don't win the world cup without Maradona, and they probably don't even get past the second round, and certainly not the quarters. They could survive the loss of any other player, though.
--
http://i48.tinypic.com/1045474.gif