LogFAQs > #967743885

I mean, they all seemed cool with him after the bathroom scene as well as Buffy trusting him to watch Dawn. This is also largely ignoring the fact that while Spike can't directly physically hurt them he teams up with Adam to try and kill all of them and works against the group on multiple occasions.

It's clear that the gang has a huge blind spot for this though, they openly welcome the murderer Andrew who, like Spike, has activley tried to kill the group on multiple occasions and, like Spike, has never shown remorse.