LogFAQs > #971089735

Finally hit my lunch break and had a little time to formulate a post. I'm trying to keep up to current while I work, but it's rough for me to actually look into things without being on a break.

HBthebattle ISO
Entirety of the first topic is just chiming in or following up on other people's conclusions. No opinions of his own, just clarifications.
1.252 Contradicts Ulti that town could have reason to DM host.
1.274 Asks for clarification on my conditional read on Plum/IGCD.
1.438 Clarifies flavor speculation on JC's role.
1.446 Speculates on Bodyguard being comparable role.
2.123 Responds to Lopen's analysis on JC role speculation.
2.279 Finally posts some original opinions, but only after being prompted by Death.
My problem with HB from this stems from the idea that he seems to be reading and keeping up with the topic, but not actually trying to find scum in any way. The only question he asked of anyone was clarification on my post. No opinions unless prompted.

Then when he wakes up to give his opinions, he gives

1. A personal tell for Lopen.
2. A description of Sbell's standard gameplay.
3. JC scum WIFOM
4. Plum's frustration with IGCD (which has recently been an opinion shared by Red!)
5. Confusion about me
6. and as far as I can tell, a joke about Chang.

This feels like two actual opinions to me and not much else.

After my vote for him. He declares he is okay with being lazy about Death and happy to just wait out the result in 2.297
HB continued to talk a little bit about Plum and IGCD's shot. But not much else.

I'm going to keep my vote on HB for the moment because the feeling I get is that he is keeping up with the reading but not contributing. Not sure if he's just having trouble making reads, but that is a common thing to look for when scum have to manufacture reads.
I'm now going to go back and try and look at Plum more closely as I feel like I don't understand exactly what's going on with his case and want to review. Red coming in and taking umbrage with Plum's random vote of all things to comment on makes me wary.