LogFAQs > #971502870

HanOfTheNekos posted...

First of all, most importantly: JC might be Scum.

For those of you who are skeptics, Ill say it like this: JC showed his hand when he didnt care whether or not Peaf lived or died. Even thinking Isquen was Town, at end of day, Peaf still was a worse lynch, given the way he was treating it. More to the point - JC was anti-Han yesterday. Who was the other person most anti-Han (aside from Sultan)? Peaf.

If JC was Town, he would have felt better about Peaf being the anti-Han, and he would have voted to save him. But he specifically did nothing in the tiebreaker.

Additionally, the lynchpin for JC was that, when I gave a post explaining my whole thing about Isquen, he brushed it off and said Well if nobody else wants to vote Han but frankly, if hes bringing the Isquen vote into question, then he would not have ignored that post. Why did he ignore it?

Because it was a good post and it hurt his stance on me. His stance on me which was Throw shade at Han because others have and maybe we can make it catch. But if he truly thought I was Scum, he would have cared who the other people aligned with him were. As he did not vote to save Peaf, he did not truly think I was Scum.

feeling like peaf was more town than you does not mean that i thought peaf was more town than isquen. there's a reason that i had peaf = dumey on the lynch list. if isquen had been on that list he probably would have been equal to them too.

anyways i was kind of hoping that i'd have the time to digest the tie, given that when plum hammered i didn't even know the full extent of what isquen had claimed. if you're proposing that i'm scum because i didn't vote isquen before i had a chance to actually fully grasp what was happening, then good luck

good OMGUS though