LogFAQs > #971503165

I followed through on my promise and did look back on Peaf's posts through D1. And... overall, my conclusion is that Peaf is likely town. His unexplained vote on me so early into the day stuck out like a sore thumb, and Peaf doesn't strike me as the kind of scum player to do something that would call plenty of attention to himself. Speaking of calling attention to himself, I liked this post from him in response to Sultan:

Peace___Frog posted...

I think it's peculiar that you got attacked for your vote but only the guy being voted and the guy tunneling on me said anything about mine.

I don't think Peaf would make this argument calling attention to his own vote as scum. Peaf is clearly out here trying to solve the game. Not to mention his demeanor at the end of the day and during the tiebreaker was very calm and cooperative. I don't think he even voted out of self-preservation, which scum Peaf could have easily done to break the tie.

By contrast, I don't think I'm too keen on Dumey. I feel like he was really hung up on Peaf for pretty much the entirety of D1, and I don't know how to feel about that. Seems a little too on-the-nose to be scummy, but it's still problematic. I did the same with Lopen in Yu-Gi-Oh Mafia by taking just one of his points and trying to paint him as scum for pretty much the entire latter half of the game.