LogFAQs > #973307336

htaeD posted...

Well if I can apply little PoE to my own notes I would argue the ones who came out looking worse were Marth and Mzero and maybe Sultan (there is more to make him look good). But not all three at once.

Then there is Corrik who hasnt done anything noteworthy and I feel his time for becoming the Corrik I know is running out. But he is not on the top of my targetlist right now.

Ctes could have done more, but does not have any bad connections to Lopen either
Sbell could have done way more and has no connections at all, which in some ways is worse.
Finally Chris is not around enough (for understandable reasons) to be put anywhere higher than neutral. Though I also feel it is too soon to call him scum, but I do think he could stand to show more offensive initiative.

But I see my top 3 choices all have a reason to not be lynched yet as well (inno scan, power claims)
Though if it came to it, I would probably pick Mzero first. But even there I hesitate.
I dont know what to make of him being the first to defend me today.

My last argument for Death is play-based. Does this look like town defending themselves from a lynch?

I can't speak for how townDeath or scumDeath would differ here as I don't have the sample-size to tell. But if I were in that situation as town, I would be trying to strongly build a case against someone as an alternate lynch. As scum, I would try to convince people that lynching claimed protection is a bad idea and try not to give up too much info on remaining town or scum one way or the other, so it can't be used against my team.

In Tekken Mafia when I got caught by a night scan, I made the mistake of hard pursuing Red before the info came out that damned me, which made it pretty much impossible to lynch Red at that time. Caught scum has to be careful with what they leave behind. Ask yourself from both perspectives. As town, does this look like giving reasonable alternatives to lynch? As scum, does this look like carefully not giving too much info?