LogFAQs > #977176705

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, Database 12 ( 11.2023-? ), Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Disney's knew movie trailer... I think the bad guy is right.
bfslick50 11/12/23 3:31:20 PM #48:	SuperSaiyanTien posted... Yeah...this is a difficult thing because (at least from this short clip) it doesn't seem like he's being villainous?? He is the king / wish granter and he decides if a wish is harmful or not and then grants it. The MC's qualm is that a bunch of wishes don't get granted...but like all wishes cannot be granted. If two people wish to be the best doctor in all the kingdom, that's impossible to grant both. What if one person wants to be the best doctor for riches while the other genuinely wants to help people? Also someone else in this thread said it best: all wishes are not equal. Sometimes people can wish for selfish things that they don't need or as the guy says they could wish for something outside of their achievable means, which in that case forgetting it might be the best for everyone. They're gonna have to really show some villainy I.E. he gains power from ungranted wishes, or he collects wishes / memories to enslave people, etc. for me to side against him. You're misrepresenting her argument. She was horrified at the memory erasure aspect. The guy who wanted to become a doctor for selfish reasons could still try on his own to be a really good doctor if he knew that he wanted to be a doctor. --- "Something's wrong! Murder isn't working and that's all we're good at." ~Futurama <cite>bfslick50 posted [p:977176705] in Disney's k... [t:80617723]...</cite> <quote>SuperSaiyanTien posted... </cite><quote>Yeah...this is a difficult thing because (at least from this short clip) it doesn't seem like he's being villainous?? He is the king / wish granter and he decides if a wish is harmful or not and then grants it. The MC's qualm is that a bunch of wishes don't get granted...but like all wishes cannot be granted. If two people wish to be the best doctor in all the kingdom, that's impossible to grant both. What if one person wants to be the best doctor for riches while the other genuinely wants to help people?Also someone else in this thread said it best: all wishes are not equal. Sometimes people can wish for selfish things that they don't need or as the guy says they could wish for something outside of their achievable means, which in that case forgetting it might be the best for everyone.They're gonna have to really show some villainy I.E. he gains power from ungranted wishes, or he collects wishes / memories to enslave people, etc. for me to side against him.</quote>You're misrepresenting her argument. She was horrified at the memory erasure aspect. The guy who wanted to become a doctor for selfish reasons could still try on his own to be a really good doctor if he knew that he wanted to be a doctor. --- "Something's wrong! Murder isn't working and that's all we're good at." ~Futurama</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1