the town just sort of bungled this at the end and it's not really scare's fault
in a final 4, 2 of the 3 townies ended the day with no vote down.
the final townie was correctly voting the scum, but one of the non-voting townies told them they refused to vote the scum and so they had to vote somewhere else. so they changed their vote, and then the person convincing them to change it didn't even place a vote - she decided she wanted to No Lynch, and thought that by not placing a vote at all, it'd count as a vote for No Lynch. Then the final townie (the one who got mislynched) was M.I.A. the whole second half of the day and showed up 1 minute past deadline to place an invalid vote.