Overrated:
Ryan Grant - Predicted at 13, finished outside of the Top 100. Injured in Week 1. Not much else to say there.
Deangelo Williams - Predicted at 10, finished at 61. Injured in Week 7, never played after that, wasn't exactly tearing it up before though.
Beanie Wells - Predicted at 16, finished at 57. Not sure how he got so high in the first place. Wishful thinking due to college success?
Ryan Mathews - Predicted at 11, finished at 32. Predicting a Rookie so high is just dumb, at any position, on any team. This guy proves it. Chargers trusted Tolbert more, and he had a much better season.
Shonn Greene - Predicted at 14, finished at 37. Somewhat similar. Everyone went with youth over experience. Experience won, and his name was LaDanian Tomlinson.
Underrated:
Peyton Hillis - Predicted at 83, finished at 4. Is it possible to be a more obscure athlete than a third-string RB on the Cleveland Browns? A year later, he scores a million touchdowns and is on the cover of Madden. And oh yes, I did pick him up off the waiver wire.
BenJarvus Green-Ellis - Not predicted within the top 100, finished at 15. Aside from having the best nickname in the NFL (the law firm), he's just a solid player. Bellichick always ****s with fantasy players with his RBs and I do not expect this to change next year.
Arian Foster - Predicted at 65, finished at 1. So much for all those people who drafted Steve Slaton expecting the second coming.
Darren McFadden - Predicted at 48, finished at 6. This one makes sense. I never believed a Raider could achieve fantasy relevance either. Everybody gets a pass on this bad prediction!
Mike Tolbert - Predicted at 79, finished at 19. See: Ryan Mathews.
--
SmartMuffin - Because anything less would be uncivilized
http://img.imgcake.com/lolkrugmanjpgry.jpg