Golden Sun's always been really divisive in my experience. To me it's just really, really average. Not something I'll probably ever replay, but not downright offensively bad.
I hope you'd at least agree that the dialogue and story are downright offensively bad!
--
West of the brick. ~*Rockets Fan*~
Epic SA-X: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QI89FfIEYU4